• Follow us

Women

Pro-Lifers Aren’t Hypocrites

In any debate about abortion, someone will eventually say that pro-lifers only care about babies until birth or only care about children in the womb, not outside of it. The pro-choice advocacy group NARAL even uses this ubiquitous cliché in an ongoing public campaign that encourages supporters to share memes spotlighting “pro-life hypocrisy.”

However, to make the claim of “pro-life hypocrisy,” one must intentionally ignore vast swaths of the pro-life movement. There are millions of people globally who advocate for the unborn and also support women, children, and those in poverty. They include the religious and non-religious, gay and straight people, people of all races and ethnicities, and, yes, both men and women (in basically equal numbers). The accusation of “pro-life hypocrisy” centers one group of conservative, pro-life voices and dismisses a multiplicity of others.

This cliché distorts our picture of the pro-life movement and is often used to dismiss the larger moral argument that a person in utero is a human being who deserves legal protection. Its invocation allows pro-choice advocates to hold their opponents to abstracted standards of radicalism in order to sidestep substantive debate.

As I survey the pro-life landscape, I see many American pro-life organizations and institutions that seek to bless women and children outside the womb. To name but a few, Feminists for Life is dedicated to “systematically eliminating the root causes that drive women to abortion—primarily lack of practical resources and support—through holistic, woman-centered solutions.” The New Wave Feminists, who made headlines last year after being removed as formal sponsors from the Women’s March simply because they’re pro-life, are “anti-war, anti-death penalty, anti-torture” and “extend this philosophy to our earliest moments of existence by also being anti-abortion.”

Consistent Life Network brings together organizations and individuals committed to the protection of all of life, which they see as diminished and threatened by “war, abortion, poverty, racism, the death penalty, and euthanasia.” And Democrats for Life work to protect life—in the words of Representative Katrina Jackson—“from the womb to the tomb.” These are not just a few, aberrant pro-life individuals but rather entire organizations and institutions engaged in diverse types of advocacy and care.

Furthermore, the church offers deeply rooted theological systems that foster holistic pro-life commitments. Catholic social teaching, for one, and its many adherents—from Dorothy Day to Pope Francis to millions of people in pews all over the world—subscribe to the idea of a “ seamless garment of life.” And, of course, there are millions of pro-life individuals “putting their money where their mouth is” by supporting mothers as well as babies, adopting and fostering children (or aiding in adoption funding), or volunteering in countless other ways.

Nonetheless, this accusation of pro-life hypocrisy emerges—and will likely persist—in a context where neither political party has a consistently pro-life ethos and platform, and that is indeed worth lamenting and seeking to change. Put simply, the incessant charge of pro-life hypocrisy is certainly a caricature, and yet—on a political level—there is still much cause for concern and much work to be done. Many evangelicals (myself included) are calling for a consistent ethic of life in part because we see rampant inconsistency in contemporary politics.

Many (though not all) Republican leaders want to curtail abortions but don’t support paid family leave or expanded family health care coverage. They favor the death penalty and resist basic gun control laws. For someone seeking a consistent ethic of life, this is frustrating. But to conflate the pro-life movement with the GOP platform is massively over-simplistic.

Indeed, it is equally frustrating that the Democratic Party has a similarly mixed commitment to life. Pro-life Democratic Governor John Bel Edward’s first act in office was to sign an executive order to expand Medicaid, providing more than 450,000 of the state’s working poor with health-care coverage. He has advocated for adoption and for a statewide living wage. He has worked to increase maternal access to pre-natal and post-natal care. So when he recently signed Louisiana’s “heartbeat bill,” did those who decry “pro-life hypocrisy” stand to applaud Governor Edwards’s consistent commitment to children (before and after birth)? No, he was roundly condemned by NARAL and his own party leadership.

To be consistently pro-life in this moment of American history is therefore to be politically homeless.

And yet, we shouldn’t simply dismiss the pro-life movement as those who don’t care about women or children after birth. What we need is not a campaign calling out “pro-life hypocrisy” but one that calls leaders (and their followers) from both parties to consistently protect the weak. We can name and lament that neither party is consistently pro-life, but this is not the same thing as dismissing the pro-life movement altogether and impugning the motives and character of millions of people who are doing what they can to support mothers and babies, both before and after birth.

Let's put that cliché to rest. Because like all clichés, it obscures as much as it reveals.

Tish Harrison Warren is a priest in the Anglican Church in North America, a member of The Pelican Project, and the author of Liturgy of the Ordinary: Sacred Practices in Everyday Life.

Current Issue Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

Women on Business

Cash Flow Is King In Ecommerce 2019-06-21 13:03:32Brought to you by Shopify: If you’re thinking about starting an ecommerce business or are currently running one today, you need to think about h

How to Use Google Ads to Grow Your 2019-06-20 21:55:21Brought to you by Web Sharx: Like it or not, Google is the internet gatekeeper. It’s certainly not the only option out there for online business

How to Care for Yourself as an Entrepreneur 2019-06-19 17:54:33How are you caring for yourself? Self-care is one of the most significant things for us entrepreneurs to learn as we grow our businesses. And it&rsquo

Great Smiles Close Deals: How Perfect Teeth Help 2019-06-17 12:18:45Brought to you by Wonderful: There is power behind a great smile. Not a lot of entrepreneurs and business professionals are aware of the opportunity t

Your Logo Design Should Be Simple and Memorable 2019-06-14 13:51:54Brought to you by LogoMyWay: Logos are visual brand identities for companies. Learn why you should KISS your logo – Keep It Simple Seriously. Di

Top 7 Best Small Business Financing Options of 2019-06-14 12:55:26Brought to you by ConstructionLoanCenter.com: Financing a small business is tricky, whether it’s in the startup stage or an expansion phase. Acc

Losing Sales Left and Right? The Top B2B 2019-06-13 12:35:54Brought to you by Apruve: Did you know that even the top rated B2B companies manage to close only 30 percent of their sales with potential prospects?

Great Business Ideas for Women at Home 2019-06-12 12:14:10Brought to you by Entrepreneur Journal Review: Many women choose to have kids and be stay-at-home moms in order to take care of their children. Howeve

How to Keep Employees Engaged 2019-06-11 18:27:26Brought to you by Blink: Managing employees is one of the challenging things that human resource managers face. It’s no lie that doing the same

10 Key Tips for Choosing the Best Accounting 2019-06-08 22:42:31Brought to you by BDN pvt networks: Many small business owners try to take on their own accounting tasks when they first launch their business, b

Allure

Paris Couture Spring 2019: The Best Hair and 2019-07-02 00:00:00It's officially Paris Haute Couture Fashion Week, which means we're in store for a laundry list of bold, daring, and of course, downright beautiful

Dior Haute Couture Fall 2019: Smoky Eye and 2019-07-01 23:40:05Backstage just a few hours before Dior's Fall 2019 Couture show, makeup artist and creative director of Christian Dior Makeup Peter Philips was prepp

Best New K-Beauty Makeup and Skin-Care Launches of 2019-07-01 17:41:22Get details on the most anticipated new beauty products from Korea hitting shelves in May, including brands like Innisfree, Mediheal, Keep Cool and mo

A Solar Eclipse Is Coming July 2: What 2019-07-01 16:43:00Here's exactly what each zodiac sign should expect from the solar eclipse in Cancer, arriving July 2. We help break down the magic and mystery of sol

California Could Become First State to Pass Anti-Hair 2019-07-01 16:07:37California to pass the CROWN Act, a bill that bans discrimination on the basis of natural hair. It will become the first state to ban hair-based discr

What Is Psoriasis? Signs and Treatment Options — 2019-07-01 15:54:00Psoriasis is one of the most common skin conditions in the U.S. With August being Psoriasis Awareness Month, here's a quick rundown of the signs and

Tyra Banks Says She Looks Like Rihanna, Receives 2019-07-01 13:55:20Tyra Banks is currently in hot water with Rihanna fans after commenting on the Fenty Beauty founder's Instagram, saying they look alike. Read more ab

Chris Pratt Gets Sunburn During Honeymoon — Photos 2019-07-01 11:06:12On his honeymoon to Hawaii with Katherine Schwarzenegger, Chris Pratt got "a touch crispy." He shared an Instagram photo of the massive red sunburn

Kim Kardashian Announces Kimono Shapewear, Gets Social Media 2019-07-01 11:00:00Fans on social media reacted after Kim Kardashian-West announced she's created a shapewear line called Kimono. Some feel that the name is an example

The Best New Hair-Care Products Dropping in July 2019-07-01 10:09:42Find out all the new hair-care products and tools launching in July. A detangling brush from Conair, blow-out cream from Kérastase, a scalp-cle

The Best New Makeup Launches Coming in July 2019-07-01 08:30:00This is the ultimate guide to the best new makeup for your eyes, lips, and face hitting the shelves in July. Find your next favorite foundation, eyeli

The Best New Beauty Products of June 2019 2019-07-01 08:30:00Welcome to Eds' Faves. These are the beauty products Allure editors vetted and voted for — our new and exciting favorite beauty picks. Sin


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.