• Follow us

Politics

Justin Trudeau's Postnationalism

Recent media coverage of a demographic study in Canada appears to show globalism’s acceleration north of the border. The elite in Canada are arguably ahead of America’s in their trajectory towards mass rootlessness, perhaps most notably observed when Prime Minister Justin Trudeau proclaimed that the country was a “postnational” nation, one that had “no core identity” anymore -- something never so explicitly stated by Barack Obama or the Democratic leadership since he left office. Alarmingly for Canada, we’re now seeing evidence that Trudeau’s declaration is becoming broadly and deeply internalized among that country’s elite. Although Canada is generally an afterthought in American politics, spreading globalism up north cannot portend well for the U.S.

A few weeks ago, major Canadian media outlets the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC), the Globe And Mail, BNN Bloomberg, and the Financial Post all ran headlines stating a variation of the following: “Think millennials are leaving Canada's big cities? Think again” (this one taken from the CBC). Each were reporting on a research note from the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC; the country’s Citigroup, basically) in which senior economist Robert Hogue concluded that millennials are apparently not leaving the cities of Vancouver, Toronto, and Montreal, as had been feared following years of sky-high property prices -- Similar to the U.S., immigrants to Canada tend to go to the major cities, pushing up rents and home prices in the process. As these outlets reported, Hogue’s research found that more millennials are actually moving to those cities than leaving them.

But just by looking at the media’s headlines, you wouldn’t have picked up that Hogue’s report did indeed say that Canadian millennials are leaving these cities en masse and that the net gain in new urban millennials is actually only due to immigrant millennials coming in from abroad e.g. foreigners between 20 and 34 who were either student-visa holders, temporary foreign workers or new permanent immigrants. As the study noted:

The number of millennials bidding farewell to Canada’s big cities pales in comparison to the number of their peers flocking in. In 2018, net immigration added a total of 76,300 young adults aged 20-34 to populations of Vancouver, Toronto and Montreal. There were also an additional 28,200 net non-permanent residents (mostly students and temporary workers) coming in from abroad and 3,800 net migrants moving from other provinces. 

Only two of the referenced outlets (the Mail and the Post) bothered to mention the outgoing Canadian millennials and, again, no outlet made it their lead. Instead of reporting on a disturbing development about young Canadians being displaced in their own cities, they all chose to cover it as a positive economic story i.e. young workers are not leaving Canada’s major cities in droves, the industries that depend on them shouldn’t worry, real-estate markets will continue to stay lofty, etc.

To ignore the real story of young Canadians’ exodus is to reject a distinction between foreign migrants and one’s conationals. That’s also the logical conclusion drawn from many of Trudeau’s other frequent decrees about Canada e.g. that ‘diversity is what makes the country strong.’ Among mainstream Canadian journalists already in this camp (likely many to most), the study’s coverage appears to show they’re now confident enough to frame their reportage in openly postnationalist terms. 

To be sure, RBC’s Hogue framed his own findings in a similar light, as seen, for instance, by the report’s title: “There’s no millennial hollowing-out of Canada’s largest cities: Future housing demand still poised to grow despite high cost.” Still, his conclusion about an exodus of young Canadians from high-priced cities was clear, and journalists could have chosen it as their lead angle, had they thought it important enough.

Hogue’s choice of framing, which was solely on economic, rather than social, terms, shouldn’t surprise. RBC is a top mortgage-originator and lender to homebuilders in Canada, and their quarterly profit expectations are closely tied to a steady and rising real-estate market. Meanwhile, Hogue’s readers, who are members of the real-estate industry, do not want to hear negative news and certainly not criticism against trends that move in their financial favor.

It’s also not surprising Hogue’s report failed to mention what helped create the exodus-inducing home-price rises in the first place: the many years of unrestrained mass immigration and foreign-homebuying in each of the mentioned cities. As former Canadian diplomat and immigration expert the late Martin Collacott routinely stated in his many appearances before parliamentary committees in Ottawa, it was the concerns of the real-estate industry in particular that motivated previous governments (conservative ones, specifically) to consistently push so hard for expanded immigration.

Canada’s drift towards deracination is important for Americans to understand because of the similarities both countries share. And although not quite there yet, the trend in the U.S. isn’t looking great. Major corporations, especially the big investment banks like RBC, are more or less the same everywhere in that they view citizens simply as cogs and consumers. As Adam Smith warned, “[a] merchant… is not necessarily the citizen of any particular country” and that a “government of an exclusive company of merchants is, perhaps, the worst of all governments for any country whatever.” Although driven by profit, rather than postmodern ideology (a key motivation for most western journalists), the grinding effect big business has on national cohesion is the same.  

As for the U.S.’s political elite, Trudeau’s ‘we’ve-no-culture-to-protect’ sentiment is still generally verboten, however, the country is seeing something similar among its lower-level politicians, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s statement that illegal aliens are more worthy or ‘more American’ than Americans themselves, or Rep. Ilhan Omar saying that many parts of America are “ignorant” and need the “perspective of a foreigner.”

The RBC report and Canada’s institutional media’s coverage of it show well the twin values of postnational globalism: the erasure of the fellow-citizen/foreigner distinction, and the championing of a free flow of foreign capital and people. Patriotic nationalism, by contrast, requires a distinction between citizen and alien, and elevates in-group considerations such as community ties, shared historical memory, and generational protection above growth-for-growth’s-sake economics. But to a postnationalist, there is no difference between Canadian millennials and foreign millennials; they both share similar economic prospects and consumer characteristics, and that’s what’s important. For average people, however, there’s plenty that is more important.

Recent media coverage of a demographic study in Canada appears to show globalism’s acceleration north of the border. The elite in Canada are arguably ahead of America’s in their trajectory towards mass rootlessness, perhaps most notably observed when Prime Minister Justin Trudeau proclaimed that the country was a “postnational” nation, one that had “no core identity” anymore -- something never so explicitly stated by Barack Obama or the Democratic leadership since he left office. Alarmingly for Canada, we’re now seeing evidence that Trudeau’s declaration is becoming broadly and deeply internalized among that country’s elite. Although Canada is generally an afterthought in American politics, spreading globalism up north cannot portend well for the U.S.

A few weeks ago, major Canadian media outlets the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC), the Globe And Mail, BNN Bloomberg, and the Financial Post all ran headlines stating a variation of the following: “Think millennials are leaving Canada's big cities? Think again” (this one taken from the CBC). Each were reporting on a research note from the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC; the country’s Citigroup, basically) in which senior economist Robert Hogue concluded that millennials are apparently not leaving the cities of Vancouver, Toronto, and Montreal, as had been feared following years of sky-high property prices -- Similar to the U.S., immigrants to Canada tend to go to the major cities, pushing up rents and home prices in the process. As these outlets reported, Hogue’s research found that more millennials are actually moving to those cities than leaving them.

But just by looking at the media’s headlines, you wouldn’t have picked up that Hogue’s report did indeed say that Canadian millennials are leaving these cities en masse and that the net gain in new urban millennials is actually only due to immigrant millennials coming in from abroad e.g. foreigners between 20 and 34 who were either student-visa holders, temporary foreign workers or new permanent immigrants. As the study noted:

The number of millennials bidding farewell to Canada’s big cities pales in comparison to the number of their peers flocking in. In 2018, net immigration added a total of 76,300 young adults aged 20-34 to populations of Vancouver, Toronto and Montreal. There were also an additional 28,200 net non-permanent residents (mostly students and temporary workers) coming in from abroad and 3,800 net migrants moving from other provinces. 

Only two of the referenced outlets (the Mail and the Post) bothered to mention the outgoing Canadian millennials and, again, no outlet made it their lead. Instead of reporting on a disturbing development about young Canadians being displaced in their own cities, they all chose to cover it as a positive economic story i.e. young workers are not leaving Canada’s major cities in droves, the industries that depend on them shouldn’t worry, real-estate markets will continue to stay lofty, etc.

To ignore the real story of young Canadians’ exodus is to reject a distinction between foreign migrants and one’s conationals. That’s also the logical conclusion drawn from many of Trudeau’s other frequent decrees about Canada e.g. that ‘diversity is what makes the country strong.’ Among mainstream Canadian journalists already in this camp (likely many to most), the study’s coverage appears to show they’re now confident enough to frame their reportage in openly postnationalist terms. 

To be sure, RBC’s Hogue framed his own findings in a similar light, as seen, for instance, by the report’s title: “There’s no millennial hollowing-out of Canada’s largest cities: Future housing demand still poised to grow despite high cost.” Still, his conclusion about an exodus of young Canadians from high-priced cities was clear, and journalists could have chosen it as their lead angle, had they thought it important enough.

Hogue’s choice of framing, which was solely on economic, rather than social, terms, shouldn’t surprise. RBC is a top mortgage-originator and lender to homebuilders in Canada, and their quarterly profit expectations are closely tied to a steady and rising real-estate market. Meanwhile, Hogue’s readers, who are members of the real-estate industry, do not want to hear negative news and certainly not criticism against trends that move in their financial favor.

It’s also not surprising Hogue’s report failed to mention what helped create the exodus-inducing home-price rises in the first place: the many years of unrestrained mass immigration and foreign-homebuying in each of the mentioned cities. As former Canadian diplomat and immigration expert the late Martin Collacott routinely stated in his many appearances before parliamentary committees in Ottawa, it was the concerns of the real-estate industry in particular that motivated previous governments (conservative ones, specifically) to consistently push so hard for expanded immigration.

Canada’s drift towards deracination is important for Americans to understand because of the similarities both countries share. And although not quite there yet, the trend in the U.S. isn’t looking great. Major corporations, especially the big investment banks like RBC, are more or less the same everywhere in that they view citizens simply as cogs and consumers. As Adam Smith warned, “[a] merchant… is not necessarily the citizen of any particular country” and that a “government of an exclusive company of merchants is, perhaps, the worst of all governments for any country whatever.” Although driven by profit, rather than postmodern ideology (a key motivation for most western journalists), the grinding effect big business has on national cohesion is the same.  

As for the U.S.’s political elite, Trudeau’s ‘we’ve-no-culture-to-protect’ sentiment is still generally verboten, however, the country is seeing something similar among its lower-level politicians, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s statement that illegal aliens are more worthy or ‘more American’ than Americans themselves, or Rep. Ilhan Omar saying that many parts of America are “ignorant” and need the “perspective of a foreigner.”

The RBC report and Canada’s institutional media’s coverage of it show well the twin values of postnational globalism: the erasure of the fellow-citizen/foreigner distinction, and the championing of a free flow of foreign capital and people. Patriotic nationalism, by contrast, requires a distinction between citizen and alien, and elevates in-group considerations such as community ties, shared historical memory, and generational protection above growth-for-growth’s-sake economics. But to a postnationalist, there is no difference between Canadian millennials and foreign millennials; they both share similar economic prospects and consumer characteristics, and that’s what’s important. For average people, however, there’s plenty that is more important.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

American Thinker

Why We Need to Stop Saying 'Health Care' 2019-07-02 01:00:00"Health care" is a progressive semantic Trojan horse. It is being used to drag us all into a political pit.

Who Will Tell the Movement Activists to Go 2019-07-02 01:00:00It turns out that power, political power, is not the meaning of life, the universe, and everything. 

Willie Brown's Ex-Girlfriend Opposes School Choice 2019-07-02 01:00:00For Kamala Harris, the ends have always justified the means.

How to Twist Numbers to Make Obama Better 2019-07-02 01:00:00As long as Obama gets all the credit...

Democrats Circling the Electoral Drain 2019-07-02 01:00:00Democrats are pushing the issues important to MSNBC and the New York Times, but not to voters.

China's New Silk Road Will Flop 2019-07-02 01:00:00Through the BRI, China hopes for nothing less than to remake the geopolitical balance of power and boldly assert itself throughout the world.

Making Sense of Common Sense 2019-07-01 01:00:00Is common sense just popularly accepted opinion? No, there's more to it than that.

Democrats are Officially the Party of Derangement 2019-07-01 01:00:00The Democrats’ clown shows last week serve as the perfect illustration of just how nuts they have become.

Where the Democrats are Trying to Take Us 2019-07-01 01:00:00The Democratic Party, as these dreadful debates last week reinforced, is now controlled by authoritarian oligarchs. 

Our So-Called 'Rights' Are Expensive! 2019-07-01 01:00:00The costly unintended consequences of Democrats' cheaply offered free stuff...

Disentangling the Renewable Energy Scam 2019-07-01 01:00:00This is how solar energy can make so much money when it's not even close to profitable.

The State Department Is Making a Mess of 2019-07-01 01:00:00Political correctness infects even the unlikeliest places.

Breaking News – Latest

An ever-expanding job for border agents: sensitive decisions 2019-07-03 14:26:43In a U.S. border patrol facility in El Paso, Texas, labels on holding cells indicate whether migrants have been selected - "yes" or "no" - for a

Harris, Gillibrand, Klobuchar call upon ORR to reform 2019-07-03 14:22:24Sens. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.), Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) and Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) wrote a letter Wednesday to the Office of Refugee Resettlement

Democrats lead GOP on 2020 generic congressional ballot 2019-07-03 14:22:08Democrats outpace Republicans in the 2020 generic ballot in two recent polls as the party seeks to build on gains it made in the House in last year's

Trump congratulates Navy SEAL found innocent of murder 2019-07-03 14:21:38 Read more at

Thunderstorm threat looms over Trump's Fourth of July 2019-07-03 14:21:04The threat of thunderstorms looms over President Donald Trump's Fourth of July celebration on the National Mall in Washington DC, but the Interior De

Senate GOP: White House backup government funding plan 2019-07-03 14:18:14Senate Republicans are raising concerns about a White House offer to use a one-year stopgap funding bill to avoid a government shutdown starting

Joe Biden raises $21.5 million in second quarter, 2019-07-03 13:37:49Former Vice President Joe Biden took in $21.5 million in the second fundraising quarter of the year, his campaign said on Wednesday, placing him behin

China's military held 'emergency response' exercises in Hong 2019-07-03 09:21:39

Buttigieg rolls out national service plan 2019-07-03 09:20:45Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg on Wednesday rolled out a national service plan that would include 1 million members by 2026.The plan

Amazon, Microsoft, and Google plot to pull product 2019-07-03 09:20:13 Rea

AOC knocks fellow Dems for refusing to pass 2019-07-02 15:25:23Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y. has taken aim at her fellow lawmakers, including those in her own party, for failing to pass measures that

Howard Kurtz: Dems making themselves vulnerable against Trump 2019-07-02 15:25:02Democratic hopefuls adopting increasingly left-wing positions could leave themselves vulnerable to attacks from President Trump in 2020, acc

Voltaire Network

Israël against the Venezuelans, by Thierry Meyssan 2019-07-02 11:48:02A new coup d'etat was attempted on 24 June in Venezuela. Thierry Meyssan reveals that it was directed both against the administration of Nicolá

G20 Osaka Leaders' Declaration 2019-07-02 11:48:02PREAMBLE 1. We, the Leaders of the G20, met in Osaka, Japan on 28-29 June 2019 to make united efforts to address major global economic challenges. We

G20 statement on preventing exploitation of the Internet 2019-07-02 11:48:02G20 OSAKA LEADERS' STATEMENT ON PREVENTING EXPLOITATION OF THE INTERNET FOR TERRORISM AND VIOLENT EXTREMISM CONDUCIVE TO TERRORISM (VECT) As leaders,

The European Union in the Pentagon's nuclear strategy, 2019-07-02 11:48:02France no longer possesses the nuclear triad (land, sea and air vectors) since 1996, and the United Kingdom has never had such weaponry. Only the Unit

Bibliography, by Thierry Meyssan 2019-07-02 11:48:021— Official Documents Australia Syria : Australian military operations, Research paper, Parliament of Australia, September 20th, 2017. 'Islamic

Washington's wager concerning Iran, by Thierry Meyssan 2019-07-02 11:48:02Even more than Syria, Iran is now at the heart of the confrontation between East and West. The astounded public is witnessing Washington's daily abou

How EU and NATO generate crises 2019-07-02 11:48:02Why are the teachers in turmoil?, by Claude Meunier-Berthelot / Test tasks in German 2017 for the examination of the basic competences (ÜGK), by

US Treasury Targets Senior IRGC Commanders Behind Iran's 2019-07-02 11:48:02The U.S. Department of the Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) took action today against eight senior commanders of Navy, Aerospace, a

Press Briefing with Jared Kushner, by Jared Kushner 2019-07-02 11:48:02Moderator: Greetings to everyone from the U.S. International Media Hub in London. I'd like to welcome our participants dialing in and thank you all f

Donald Trump Executive Order to Impose Sanctions on 2019-07-02 11:48:02Today, the White House issued an Executive Order sanctioning the Supreme Leader's Office and authorizing further sanctions on those associated with i

We are all liars, by Thierry Meyssan 2019-06-10 07:23:00Thierry Meyssan reacts to the commemoration of D-Day in Normandy, the commemoration of the massacre at Tiananmen, and to the campaign for the election

The long arm of the Bilderberg Group, by 2019-06-10 07:23:00For the last few years, many ridiculous stories have been written about the Bilderberg Group. However, working from the documents, it is possible to p

rss

Student Active-shooter Deaths 9 Times as Likely With 2019-07-02 19:30:00Question: Would you put a sign on your lawn stating “This Home is Proudly Gun Free”? No? Don’t worry, some years back pro-gun-contro

After Iran Breaches Uranium Enrichment Limit, Many Fear 2019-07-02 18:00:00Iran has significantly increased tension in the Middle East by breaching the urainium enrichment standards set by the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Acti

Another Video Provides Evidence Smollett Staged Hate Hoax 2019-07-02 17:40:00More video has surfaced providing evidence homosexual actor Jussie Smollett staged an elaborate hate-crime hoax.

Colin Kaepernick Lands Nike in Hot Water Over 2019-07-02 17:00:00Colin Kaepernick has used his influence with Nike to have the company’s American flag-themed shoe called the “Betsy Ross” pulled fro

CIS Report: 35K Africans Heading for U.S. Border 2019-07-02 17:00:00The news that Congolese possibly infected with Ebola virus were streaming across the southwest border of the United States with the tsunami of Central

China Conducts Naval Exercises and Ballistic Missile Tests 2019-07-02 16:00:00China is holding military exercises in the South China Sea, and has also carried out the first of a series of anti-ship ballistic missile tests in the

CNN Poll: Biden Down 10 Points, Harris Up 2019-07-02 11:55:00With the cratering of Biden following his woeful performance last Thursday, it's becoming clear that the real winner of the first Democrat debate was

IKEA Faces Backlash After Firing Worker Over Biblical 2019-07-02 11:25:01IKEA is facing intense backlash after firing an employee in Poland over his Christian opposition to homosexuality.

Garfield Assassination Causes Creation of Civil Service System 2019-07-02 11:20:00Today marks the anniversary of the assassination of President James Abram Garfield in 1881, an act which led directly to the passage of the Pendleton

Calif. Assembly Approves Resolution That Calls for Church 2019-07-02 10:15:00The state assembly of California has approved a nonbinding resolution that would require churches to accept the LGBTQ lifestyle. 

Illegal-alien Mob Demands Entry at El Paso, CBP 2019-07-02 09:51:08A mob of angry “migrants” threatened to cross the U.S. border by force at a crossing in El Paso yesterday, yet another indication not just

July 2 Is the Anniversary of American Independence 2019-07-02 09:33:00If America decided to declare independence from Britain on July 2, why do we celebrate our independence on July 4?

Christian Science Monitor |

Car but no home? Safe parking lots spread 2019-07-02 11:45:39Safe parking lots to sleep in help the homeless who own vehicles with wraparound services in the evenings.

Onstage, Democrats clash on ideas. Offstage, is there 2019-07-02 11:45:39The two-night Democratic debates in Miami highlighted the divide between pragmatists and progressives. But offstage, there was more common ground.

How are slave descendants, Jesuits working to reconcile? 2019-07-02 11:45:39After a promising first meeting in 2017, Jesuits affiliated with Georgetown and descendants of enslaved people are working to find common ground. 

With redistricting decision, high court draws line on 2019-07-02 11:45:39The Supreme Court ruled that federal courts are powerless to rule on political gerrymandering. But states are moving toward reform on their own.

Census case: Why a measure of citizenry won’t 2019-07-02 11:45:39In a 5-4 ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court Thursday blocked the addition of a citizenship question to the 2020 census.

Did Warren win the first debate – or 2019-07-02 11:45:39Saying she would eliminate private health insurance may win progressive votes for Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren – but could alienate moder

Border aid package breezes through Senate 2019-07-02 11:45:39The Senate passed a $4.6 billion border aid bill to deliver aid to migrant families and unaccompanied children. The GOP-controlled Senate rejected a p

Why Democrats can’t break out of the ‘electability’ 2019-07-02 11:45:39The 2020 race is being framed once again around electability, a concept that’s both reflective of – and has a direct impact on –&nbs

E. Jean Carroll: She said, he said, and 2019-07-02 11:45:39Why didn't The New York Times and other media outlets give E. Jean Carroll sexual assault charges against Trump bigger play?

Robert Mueller agrees to testify 2019-07-02 11:45:39After asking to let his report speak for itself, former special counsel Robert Mueller will testify after all, beginning July 17, with back-to-back ap

Border aid package passes the House, but faces 2019-07-02 11:45:39The House bill contains more than $4 billion combined for supplies and unaccompanied migrant children's care. But the White House could block the bil

Overruled: Is precedent in danger at the Supreme 2019-07-02 11:45:39As this year’s term closes, the conservative-majority United States Supreme Court is placing a shrinking value on legal precedent.

Reuters: Politics

Trump is 'very fond' of Palestinian President Abbas, 2019-07-03 14:00:54White House adviser Jared Kushner said on Wednesday the United States is willing to engage with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas but hinted a new p

Trump casts himself, military, Republican VIPs as stars 2019-07-03 13:35:00U.S. military armored vehicles stood near Washington's majestic Lincoln Memorial on Wednesday as President Donald Trump pushed ahead with an elaborat

Joe Biden raises $21.5 million in second quarter, 2019-07-03 13:27:51Former Vice President Joe Biden took in $21.5 million in the second fundraising quarter of the year, his campaign said on Wednesday, placing him behin

U.S. probes border patrol as criticism of detention 2019-07-03 13:27:12The acting head of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has ordered an investigation into reports that Border Patrol agents have been posting offe

An ever-expanding job for border agents: sensitive decisions 2019-07-03 13:27:12In a U.S. border patrol facility in El Paso, Texas, labels on holding cells indicate whether migrants have been selected - "yes" or "no" - for a

Tanks in Washington ahead of Trump's Fourth of 2019-07-03 13:21:42Battle tanks were seen on a train in Washington on Tuesday ahead of a July Fourth celebration highlighting U.S. military might that Democrats say Pres

Biden's support from black voters cut in half 2019-07-03 13:00:00Former Vice President Joe Biden, the early front-runner for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination, has lost support among African-Americans afte

FHFA special advisor Bob Ryan to leave July 2019-07-03 12:59:05Bob Ryan, a special advisor to the head of the Federal Housing Finance Agency, will depart from the agency, which oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac,

U.S. Justice Department watchdog to probe FBI role 2019-07-03 12:26:41The U.S. Justice Department's watchdog will review the role of the FBI and Justice Department in a reversal of plans to move FBI headquarters to the

Trump denies administration's retreat on census citizenship question 2019-07-03 12:26:09President Donald Trump on Wednesday said his administration had not dropped its efforts to add a contentious citizenship question to the 2020 U.S. cen

'Help, 40 days here': Photos show migrants crammed 2019-07-03 11:21:04Government investigators warned of dangerous overcrowding at more migrant facilities on the southwest U.S. border, publishing photos on Tuesday of pac

U.S. DHS boss orders probe into border agents' 2019-07-03 10:00:03The U.S. Department of Homeland Security's acting secretary, Kevin McAleenan, has ordered an investigation into reports that border patrol agents hav


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.