• Follow us

Politics

What's Beto's Problem with the Constitution?

When "Beto" O'Rourke recently questioned whether the basic principles of the Constitution still apply in today's world, what exactly did he mean?  Which principles would he reject, and what new principles would he substitute for our governance?

At a time when our Constitution is increasingly attacked as unfair, immoral and obsolete, or simply irrelevant, the pronouncements of political figures such as O'Rourke matter.  O'Rourke is a rising star of the left and a presumed 2020 presidential candidate who, as it happens, comes from Texas, a state with a large number of electoral votes.

To get an idea of O'Rourke's principles, we might look to his recent failed Senate run.  His campaign platform lists 17 major issue categories.  Within O'Rourke's 17 categories are over 75 specific initiatives.

As might be expected, a review of his platform's top initiatives reveals a strong alignment with the progressive left on nearly every point: health care a "basic human right," ensuring "guaranteed due process" as well as citizenship for illegal immigrants, correcting "bias" in the criminal justice system, increasing public funding for "underserved communities," "protecting" teachers' pensions, and much more.

Within this potpourri of regulation, handouts, and carveouts, we can discern a common thread:  a larger role for government -- specifically the federal government -- tacitly justified by a deluge of empathy.

O'Rourke's platform aligns neatly with Franklin D. Roosevelt's "second bill of rights" of the 1940s, which viewed the Constitution as inadequate and proposed a vast expansion of federal power and reach as a correction.  In more recent times, FDR's view was embraced by Barack Obama, who described the Constitution dismissively as a "charter of negative liberties."  O'Rourke is only the latest in a long line of progressives who plainly have trouble with the Constitution.

Yet if O'Rourke's platform contains any actual new "principles of governance" that are somehow superior to the Constitution's and presumably should supersede them, they are obscured by the gratuitous empathy that motivates his initiatives.  O'Rourke simply identifies numerous "victims" and makes himself their gallant champion.

In the realm of civics, it is vital to be skeptical of empathy.  Viewed cynically, empathy is politically useful inasmuch as it makes it easy to seduce the persuadable to your side, and it opens the door wide to politically useful virtue-signaling.

But viewed realistically, empathy in civic discourse is insidious and corrosive.  It is wholly incompatible with rational judgment and sober decision-making -- hallmarks of good governance.  Instead, empathy empowers a few individuals to hijack civic priorities, irrespective of facts and in circumvention of just process.  Empathy demands compassionate action regardless of any obstacles -- never mind that resources are always and everywhere limited.  Empathy privileges certain preferred choices over others, without regard to their relative worthiness -- necessarily trampling the legitimate rights of the truly worthy.  Empathy silences opposing points of view, as its claim to the moral high ground makes it virtually immune to criticism.

Does O'Rourke actually understand the real principles at the foundation of the Constitution?  Does he appreciate their wisdom and importance?

The Founders were learned men, keen students of human history and human nature, who had endured tyranny firsthand.  They understood human weakness and fallibility.  They observed the corrupting influence of power on leadership.  They appreciated the essential limits and inadequacies of every sort of governance and authority.  They respected that individuals, men and women -- and only they -- are the proper guardians of their destiny.

These are durable, unchanging, inherent principles of humankind, and the Constitution embodies this found wisdom.  In devising a new form of government, the Founders incorporated these understandings through a variety of structural limitations, controls and "checks and balances" upon government, and upon those who hold office.  The Bill of Rights further embodies key concepts of liberty, most importantly the principle of inalienable rights, that additionally restrict the powers of the federal government.  This formula of restrained government as an enabler of unprecedented social and economic freedom, combined with individual enterprise, produced the wealthiest and most beneficent nation on Earth, and we are its fortunate inheritors.

Beto O'Rourke is simply wrong to declare these principles obsolete.  Human nature has not changed.  The passage of "230-plus years" since the Constitution's adoption makes no difference whatsoever.

Is O'Rourke merely ignorant of this basic truth?  O'Rourke calls for a "discussion" on these principles, but it is hard to see this as anything other than their implicit rejection.  More likely, holding his own views as incontrovertible, O'Rourke arrogantly seeks to control the affairs of American citizens and will use the power of government to achieve his ends.  For such purposes the Constitution is decidedly an obstacle and not an enabler.

But who is Beto, or any of his philosophical predecessors and cohorts, to make intimate decisions and judgments for others' lives, families and destinies?  Election to office is not such a license, as the Founders understood.  It takes stupendous hubris, conceit, and a wholly unjustified sense of personal righteousness, to usurp this privilege.

Only a sound and respected republican Constitution will prevent people like O'Rourke from putting the government in charge of literally everything. 

When "Beto" O'Rourke recently questioned whether the basic principles of the Constitution still apply in today's world, what exactly did he mean?  Which principles would he reject, and what new principles would he substitute for our governance?

At a time when our Constitution is increasingly attacked as unfair, immoral and obsolete, or simply irrelevant, the pronouncements of political figures such as O'Rourke matter.  O'Rourke is a rising star of the left and a presumed 2020 presidential candidate who, as it happens, comes from Texas, a state with a large number of electoral votes.

To get an idea of O'Rourke's principles, we might look to his recent failed Senate run.  His campaign platform lists 17 major issue categories.  Within O'Rourke's 17 categories are over 75 specific initiatives.

As might be expected, a review of his platform's top initiatives reveals a strong alignment with the progressive left on nearly every point: health care a "basic human right," ensuring "guaranteed due process" as well as citizenship for illegal immigrants, correcting "bias" in the criminal justice system, increasing public funding for "underserved communities," "protecting" teachers' pensions, and much more.

Within this potpourri of regulation, handouts, and carveouts, we can discern a common thread:  a larger role for government -- specifically the federal government -- tacitly justified by a deluge of empathy.

O'Rourke's platform aligns neatly with Franklin D. Roosevelt's "second bill of rights" of the 1940s, which viewed the Constitution as inadequate and proposed a vast expansion of federal power and reach as a correction.  In more recent times, FDR's view was embraced by Barack Obama, who described the Constitution dismissively as a "charter of negative liberties."  O'Rourke is only the latest in a long line of progressives who plainly have trouble with the Constitution.

Yet if O'Rourke's platform contains any actual new "principles of governance" that are somehow superior to the Constitution's and presumably should supersede them, they are obscured by the gratuitous empathy that motivates his initiatives.  O'Rourke simply identifies numerous "victims" and makes himself their gallant champion.

In the realm of civics, it is vital to be skeptical of empathy.  Viewed cynically, empathy is politically useful inasmuch as it makes it easy to seduce the persuadable to your side, and it opens the door wide to politically useful virtue-signaling.

But viewed realistically, empathy in civic discourse is insidious and corrosive.  It is wholly incompatible with rational judgment and sober decision-making -- hallmarks of good governance.  Instead, empathy empowers a few individuals to hijack civic priorities, irrespective of facts and in circumvention of just process.  Empathy demands compassionate action regardless of any obstacles -- never mind that resources are always and everywhere limited.  Empathy privileges certain preferred choices over others, without regard to their relative worthiness -- necessarily trampling the legitimate rights of the truly worthy.  Empathy silences opposing points of view, as its claim to the moral high ground makes it virtually immune to criticism.

Does O'Rourke actually understand the real principles at the foundation of the Constitution?  Does he appreciate their wisdom and importance?

The Founders were learned men, keen students of human history and human nature, who had endured tyranny firsthand.  They understood human weakness and fallibility.  They observed the corrupting influence of power on leadership.  They appreciated the essential limits and inadequacies of every sort of governance and authority.  They respected that individuals, men and women -- and only they -- are the proper guardians of their destiny.

These are durable, unchanging, inherent principles of humankind, and the Constitution embodies this found wisdom.  In devising a new form of government, the Founders incorporated these understandings through a variety of structural limitations, controls and "checks and balances" upon government, and upon those who hold office.  The Bill of Rights further embodies key concepts of liberty, most importantly the principle of inalienable rights, that additionally restrict the powers of the federal government.  This formula of restrained government as an enabler of unprecedented social and economic freedom, combined with individual enterprise, produced the wealthiest and most beneficent nation on Earth, and we are its fortunate inheritors.

Beto O'Rourke is simply wrong to declare these principles obsolete.  Human nature has not changed.  The passage of "230-plus years" since the Constitution's adoption makes no difference whatsoever.

Is O'Rourke merely ignorant of this basic truth?  O'Rourke calls for a "discussion" on these principles, but it is hard to see this as anything other than their implicit rejection.  More likely, holding his own views as incontrovertible, O'Rourke arrogantly seeks to control the affairs of American citizens and will use the power of government to achieve his ends.  For such purposes the Constitution is decidedly an obstacle and not an enabler.

But who is Beto, or any of his philosophical predecessors and cohorts, to make intimate decisions and judgments for others' lives, families and destinies?  Election to office is not such a license, as the Founders understood.  It takes stupendous hubris, conceit, and a wholly unjustified sense of personal righteousness, to usurp this privilege.

Only a sound and respected republican Constitution will prevent people like O'Rourke from putting the government in charge of literally everything. 

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

American Thinker

With a Song in the Heart of Israel 2019-02-08 01:00:00The news that the Eurovision song contest will be held in Tel Aviv has produced an outcry of unrelenting hostility toward the State of Israe

Virginia Politics and the Death of 'I Believe 2019-02-08 01:00:00Will Democrats stick to the "me too" narrative now that one of their own is in the crosshairs – and that the governorship of Virginia hangs in

President Trump's SOTU Affirmed Liberty to Unresponsive Subversives 2019-02-08 01:00:00Pres. Donald Trump spat in the face of the socialists and socialists in sheep's clothing of the Democratic Party.

Electronic Health Records Give Way to Disasters and 2019-02-08 01:00:00Electronic health record systems mandated by Congress have put patients and their privacy at risk

American Enterprise Will Beat China in Outer Space 2019-02-08 01:00:00"China is best placed to win a space race," whined the Washington Post. Forget about it.

The Myth of the Media 2019-02-08 01:00:00The media of today are not about news.

What's Beto's Problem with the Constitution? 2019-02-07 01:00:00When "Beto" O'Rourke questions whether the basic principles of the Constitution still apply in today's world, what exactly does he mean?

Infanticidal Democrats Took Their Cues from Barack Obama 2019-02-07 01:00:00Obama was the advocate par excellence of baby-killing.

Fake News about Holes in Antarctic Glaciers 2019-02-07 01:00:00CNN is breathless, but there are a couple of things the network forgot to consider.

The Democratic Party and the Decline of the 2019-02-07 01:00:00Can any Democrat who can appeal to a broad-based, non-ideological electorate win the Democratic nomination?

Trump's Schedule and the Value of the President's 2019-02-07 01:00:00Liberals who throw a fit about the president's White House schedule have no idea what they're talking about.

The Progessives and Your Money 2019-02-07 01:00:00The Progressive Party has several new faces poised to lead the way and show the country the path we need to take. 

Breaking News – Latest

Trump-Powell dinner on Monday 'constructive': White House official 2019-02-07 15:33:11This week's dinner between U.S. President Donald Trump and the chairman of the Federal Reserve was "constructive" after a rocky few months, a top W

Border Patrol officer charged with illegally selling firearms 2019-02-07 15:33:02A U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CPB) officer was arrested and charged with illegally selling guns.

Rep. Liz Cheney Says Infanticide, Late-Term Abortion Debate 2019-02-07 15:32:33GOP Rep. Liz Cheney of Wyoming called late-term abortion “pure evil” on “Fox & Friends” Thursday, adding the issue shouldn

Arizona proposal would hike tobacco tax to fund 2019-02-07 15:32:03An Arizona state lawmaker has proposed a resolution to hike the tax consumers pay on cigarettes and similar tobacco products in order to fund col

Dem Rep. Bobby Scott learned of accusation against 2019-02-07 15:31:21Rep. Bobby Scott, D-Va., was made aware of an allegation of sexual assault against Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax more than a year ago, an aide told Fox

U.S. lawmakers renew push for penalties against Saudi 2019-02-07 15:31:17Republican and Democratic U.S. lawmakers renewed their push on Thursday to penalize Saudi Arabia for the murder of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi an

Democratic Senator Tester says border deal possible this 2019-02-07 15:31:11U.S. Democratic Senator Jon Tester, a member of the committee trying to reach an agreement on border security, said a deal was possible as early as Fr

Grassley says Senate won't revisit provision of GOP 2019-02-07 15:31:03Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) is throwing cold water on the idea of revising a key provision in the GOP tax law after President Trump said he was open

Trump confirms he won't meet with China's Xi 2019-02-07 15:30:28President Donald Trump confirmed on Thursday that he did not plan to meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping before a March 1 deadline set by the two c

Pompeo reassures allies of U.S. commitment to defeat 2019-02-06 14:40:45U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Wednesday reassured coalition partners that the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Syria was not "the end of Ameri

John Bolton says Venezuela's Maduro could end up 2019-02-01 13:32:38The Trump administration has ratcheted up the pressure on the government of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro in recent weeks, recognizing an opposi

California Restaurateur Compares MAGA Hats to White Hoods 2019-02-01 13:32:12By now much of America has seen the images of teenage boys in “Make America Great Again” hats milling near a chanting Native American elde

Voltaire Network

Iran is cornered, by Thierry Meyssan 2019-02-07 09:23:09The United States are preparing to organise the « Greater Middle East » without their troops. They will probably capitalise on the errors

Whitestream can identify parties to Bitcoin transactions 2019-02-07 09:23:09The virtual currency, Bitcoin, offers you the assurance that noone will know about your transaction. That is Bitcoin's key sales pitch. But the Israe

Erik Prince invests in China 2019-02-07 09:23:09Erik Prince, founder of Blackwater, has not only invested in the United Arab Emirates but also in China, specifically in Xinqiang. Citic, the Chinese

France put the pressure on Egypt keep its 2019-02-07 09:23:09The daily newspaper, Al Hayat, has cited the Egyptian Minister of Foreign Affairs, Sameh Shukri as saying that the French President, Emmanuel Macron,

Washington, the logic of force, by Manlio Dinucci 2019-02-07 09:23:09During the attacks on 11 September 2001, Secretary for Defense Donald Rumsfeld and his advisor, Arthur Cebrowski, defined the Pentagon's need to domi

Italy placed its veto to the EU recognizing 2019-02-07 09:23:09The Italian government announced that it vetoed the EU's recognition of Juan Guaidó as the “Acting President” when the Council of

The US burial of the INF Treaty with 2019-02-07 09:23:09The Pentagon has decided to install medium-range nuclear missiles in Europe, which would turn this territory into a battle-field in case of a war betw

Lima Group Declaration 2019-02-07 09:23:09The Governments of Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Guatemala, Honduras, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, members of the Lima Group, exp

Human Fraternity for World Peace and Living Together, 2019-02-07 09:23:09INTRODUCTION Faith leads a believer to see in the other a brother or sister to be supported and loved. Through faith in God, who has created the unive

EU now sees Gibraltar as a UK “colony” 2019-02-07 09:23:09On 1 February 2019 the EU published a document which classified Gibralta as a “Crown Colony”. This has caused London to break out in a ras

The 116th US Congress is preparing a new 2019-02-01 09:58:47We were wrong to think that the Syrians were out of danger after their victory over the jihadists. They are not. Israël and the United States hav

Venezuela, a putsch by the US deep state, 2019-02-01 09:58:47Finally, President Trump has aligned himself with the ambitions of the US deep state for the destruction of the Caribbean Basin. He has confirmed Vice

rss

Has Trump Found the Formula for 2020? 2019-02-08 12:03:15If the pollsters at CNN and CBS are correct, Donald Trump may have found the formula for winning a second term in 2020.

AOC and Pals: Abolish ICE 2019-02-08 11:40:00Yesterday, the Democrats found out that their new stars aren’t merely leftists approaching the definition of communist, but instead are so unmoo

Get Them Out! 2019-02-08 10:57:00The American people, and parents in particular, are now faced with two stark choices: Withdraw from the public education system in massive numbers, or

Christians Getting Out 2019-02-08 10:50:00After acknowledging that leftists control the content of public schools and are propagandizing the children to their views, Ray Moore decided to get t

Disney Hosting First Official LGBTQ Event at Paris 2019-02-08 10:44:00For the first time ever Disney is going officially gay for a day as it hosts its LGBTQ-themed “Magical Pride” event in Paris.

Alex in Wonderland: AOC’s Green New Deal Would 2019-02-08 10:31:00It will take only 10 years, claims Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, to completely overhaul the American economy — achieving net-zero CO2

Foreign Aid Advocates Dislike Trump Nominee for World 2019-02-07 18:37:00After President Donald Trump named David Robert Malpass to succeed Jim Yong Kim as president of the World Bank, many in the pro-foreign aid establishm

As New Migrant Caravan Arrives at the Border, 2019-02-07 18:09:00As a new migrant caravan arrives near Eagle Pass, Texas, President Trump prepares to take his case for a border wall directly to the people.

The Case for Christian Education 2019-02-07 15:22:00Scripture and church fathers clearly state that education should be God-centered, but God is banned from public schools.

Benefits of Homeschooling 2019-02-07 15:08:00A man who has been involved with the resurgence of homeschooling in America talks about the many benefits of it.

Black Lives Matter Invades Schools Nationwide 2019-02-07 14:35:00Across America this week, government schools and teachers are celebrating “Black Lives Matter Week” by indoctrinating innocent children in

Va. Plot Thickens: Northam Picked Mayor With Criminal 2019-02-07 14:22:00The Democratic leadership in Virginia is in such turmoil at the top that the commonwealth’s constitutional line of succession would put the Repu

Christian Science Monitor |

Blackface photo reopens long history of racial bias 2019-02-06 19:00:47A racist photo in Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam's 1984 medical school yearbook has not only caused a political furore but also for some 

Puerto Rico's bleak finances brighten with debt restructuring 2019-02-06 19:00:47Four years after Puerto Rico defaulted on billions of dollars in bonds, a federal judge has approved a debt restructuring deal that will help bon

House committee expected to give Mueller transcripts from 2019-02-06 19:00:47The House Intelligence Committee votes today on whether it should cooperate with special counsel Robert Mueller regarding the Russia investigation, po

In SOTU, Trump says enough with 'resistance' politics 2019-02-06 19:00:47President Trump's State of the Union speech sought to shore up Republican support that had eroded slightly during the recent government shutdown.&nbs

For political stars like Beto and Stacey, powerful 2019-02-06 19:00:47Stacey Abrams will deliver the Democratic response to the State of the Union tonight, while Beto O’Rourke will be interviewed live by Oprah &nda

US, Russia back off nuclear treaty. Is arms 2019-02-06 19:00:47If the landmark Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty is truly entering its last days, it may signal that the world’s two nuclear superpowers

The team everyone loves to hate, Patriots in 2019-02-06 19:00:47From their famous work ethic to their steely mental discipline to their success working together as a team, the NFL champs have given a model for how

Ann Coulter wants a wall. But does Trump 2019-02-06 19:00:47As President Trump prepares to address the nation Tuesday, he’s under withering attack from once-friendly conservative quarters. Some strategist

‘Be a man’: What does that mean in 2019-02-06 19:00:47Beyond angst over ads and concern that America is afraid to let boys be boys, there are areas of agreement: Neither men nor women should be boxed into

Super Bowl: With Saints not in, this town’s 2019-02-06 19:00:47It is said that the test of true fandom comes not with victory but with defeat. Saints fans have met their latest trial with the relentless spiri

States spend millions on outreach work to avoid 2019-02-06 19:00:47Ahead of the decennial census next year, some states are focusing enormous resources to reach those individuals deemed hardest to count. An under

Trump blames Russia as US pulls out of 2019-02-06 19:00:47Citing Russia's failure to comply, the Trump administration has moved to dissolve the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, an arms control agree

Reuters: Politics

No talks between Trump and China's Xi before 2019-02-08 04:00:12U.S. President Donald Trump said on Thursday he did not plan to meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping before a March 1 deadline set by the two countr

Acting U.S. Attorney Gen Whitaker to testify before 2019-02-08 03:17:08U.S. House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerry Nadler said on Thursday that acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker will testify on Friday, after he t

Acting U.S. attorney general will testify before House 2019-02-08 03:17:08Acting U.S. Attorney General Matthew Whitaker has agreed to testify on Friday before the House Judiciary Committee, the Justice Department said on Thu

John Dingell, longest-serving member of U.S. Congress, dead 2019-02-08 00:53:05John Dingell, a gruff Michigan Democrat who entered the U.S. House of Representatives in 1955 to finish his late father's term and became a legislati

Senate committee to consider resolution against Nord Stream 2019-02-07 22:47:35Republican and Democratic U.S. senators on Thursday unveiled a resolution calling for the cancellation of Russia's Nord Stream 2 natural gas pipeline

Trump stokes Democrats' Virginia turmoil as scandal snares 2019-02-07 22:06:14A firestorm of scandals embroiling Virginia's governor and two fellow Democrats at the top of the state's executive branch spread to the Republican

House panel pledges to work with acting AG 2019-02-07 21:44:28The head of the U.S. House Judiciary Committee said on Thursday the panel was ready to work with acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker to address c

Democrats float 'Green New Deal' to end fossil 2019-02-07 21:40:12Democrats on Thursday laid out a "Green New Deal" that would eliminate U.S. greenhouse gas emissions within a decade, an effort to make climate chan

House Democrats question IRS audits of Trump taxes 2019-02-07 21:20:31Democrats in Congress raised questions on Thursday about the Internal Revenue Service's ability to effectively audit President Donald Trump's tax re

U.S. border security talks progressing: negotiators 2019-02-07 21:06:38U.S. lawmakers negotiating a deal with President Donald Trump on border security funding on Thursday said progress was being made, with Democratic Sen

Mueller eyes Manafort meeting with Russian partner in 2019-02-07 19:48:58U.S. Special Counsel Robert Mueller is focused on a meeting at the height of the 2016 presidential campaign between Donald Trump's then campaign chai

House panel passes bill targeting OPEC oil supply 2019-02-07 17:51:31A U.S. House of Representatives committee approved a bill on Thursday that would open up the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries to anti


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.