• Follow us


Internal Google Panel to Vet AI Projects Packed With Executives

(Bloomberg) -- Two weeks ago, Google established an external panel of experts to review thorny ethical issues related to artificial intelligence. It quickly imploded. After a staff revolt over the panel's members, the company disbanded the panel on Thursday afternoon. Its members never even got the chance to meet. 

The episode illustrates the difficulty Google is having as it grapples with the societal implications of the powerful technology shaping its future. It’s hard to overstate how important AI is to the company. “It’s more profound than, I don’t know, electricity or fire,” said Sundar Pichai, the company’s chief executive officer, last year. But Google has been at the center of a widening public debate over how automated systems might disadvantage vulnerable groups or lead to large-scale job losses, and whether AI should be incorporated into weaponry. 

The capability of Google’s panel – the Advanced Technology External Advisory Council, or ATEAC – to confront such issues was never entirely clear. But another group with a nearly identical name – the Advanced Technology Review Council – does hold real power to shape Google’s approach to its ethical quandaries.  

The company describes this other council, which it assembled last year, as an attempt to “represent diverse, international, cross-functional points of view that can look beyond immediate commercial concerns,” according to documents viewed by Bloomberg News. It has not publicly released the names of its members, but it includes some of the most influential people at the company, who have worked for years with Pichai and his boss, Google co-founder Larry Page, according to people familiar with the group.

This council is run by Kent Walker, Google's chief legal officer. The other members are Urs Hölzle, Google's infrastructure chief; Jeff Dean, head of AI; Jacquelline Fuller, vice president for Google.org; Maggie Johnson, vice president of education and university programs; and Mustafa Suleyman, co-founder of DeepMind, a leading AI research firm owned by Google parent Alphabet Inc. 

Critics familiar with the council see it as a whitewash. They say a board of top executives is unlikely to serve as a serious check on Google in situations where its stated ethical principles butt up against its financial interests. And multiple people inside the company said the agenda and decisions of this corporate board remain unclear months after launching. These people asked not to be identified for fear of retaliation.  

When asked for comment, a Google spokesman pointed to a blog post in December that first introduced the group, highlighting the company’s progress in implementing its ethical principles on AI. At that time, the company had conducted 100 reviews. In the blog post, Walker noted that the company had decided to hold off on a general-use facial recognition tool “before working through important technology and policy questions.” 

Many technology companies have recently laid out ethical principles to guide their work on AI. Microsoft Corp.; Facebook Inc.; and Axon, which makes stun guns and body cameras for police departments, all now have advisory boards on the issue. But experts question whether these actions are designed primarily to head off new government regulations. “Ethical codes may deflect criticism by acknowledging that problems exist, without ceding any power to regulate or transform the way technology is developed and applied,” wrote the AI Now Institute, a research group at New York University, in a 2018 report. “We have not seen strong oversight and accountability to backstop these ethical commitments.”

AI Now’s report noted that Google had pursued a censored version of its search engine for the Chinese market, even after it had released a set of principles that seemed to preclude such a project on human rights grounds. 

Google’s AI strategy first ran into serious ethical concerns last year, when revelations about its work on a drone initiative called Project Maven led to staff protests and work stoppages. Last June, it released a set of ethical AI principles and created multiple committees to vote on whether proposed products meet the criteria. These groups are similar to the way Google reviews services, like advertising and mobile software, for privacy guidelines and legal liability. For AI, there's a "Responsible Innovation team," led by 12-year Google veteran Jen Gennai, which handles "day-to-day operations" and refers issues to an overarching board, according to the December company blog post. Another larger group of advisers, comprised of less senior staff, is on call for in-house expertise on technical products and protocols.

Those two sit below the highest review board, the Advanced Technology Review Council, which will "help resolve complex issues surfaced by [Google's] review process," the internal document said.

The short life of the external council was a case study in the company’s vitriolic internal politics. Within hours of its formation, outrage quickly built among staff members who objected to Google’s inclusion of Kay Coles James, president of the Heritage Foundation, and her prior public comments about gay and transgender people and climate change. A petition calling for her removal began circulating. One member of the board resigned, while another defended the decision to stay. Right-wing news outlets published leaked messages from employees criticizing James. Breitbart News described messages harshly criticizing James as “outright smears.” The Heritage Foundation did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Friday.

Joanna Bryson, a computer science professor at the University of Bath who was invited to Google’s external board, described its collapse as a major setback. “The bottom line is that we are back at the status quo, which personally I think is unacceptable,” she wrote in an email. 

Google seems no closer to coming up with an approach that will satisfy anyone. On Thursday, when the company shuttered its external council, a company statement said it was "going back to the drawing board." It made no mention of the internal panel.  

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News


The biggest challenges of building a custom chat 2019-04-02 06:30:46Like everything worthwhile in life, building a chat app will pose some challenges.

CloudFlare adds free VPN to DNS app 2019-04-02 06:30:18It promises more speed, reliability, security and privacy.

Google+ finally closes down 2019-04-02 06:00:55Pages and profiles are getting deleted from today.

Insurers who don’t digitally transform risk being left 2019-04-02 06:00:08Insurtechs, and more worryingly Big Techs, are eyeing up how they seize distribution.

Avoiding AI's darkest future - is ethical AI 2019-04-02 05:30:04The guidelines for AI security and ethics needs to be established.

Making Tax Digital is as much about cultivating 2019-04-02 05:00:04Making Tax Digital is a watershed moment for an industry that has been on the trailing edge of digitalisation, it will take skill to survive the futur

The ROI of customer data 2019-04-02 04:30:42Clucas discusses how organisations can create opportunities for data collection and strategies to effectively leverage insights.

Engineering culture - The key to successful digital 2019-04-02 04:00:33Is your engineering culture affecting the success of your digital delivery?

What is ransomware? Everything you need to know 2019-04-01 11:09:40Ransomware: What’s new 01/04 - FEATURE - Alastair Bloom/Logicalis UK - Theft, ransomware and vandalism- Securing your data is getting tougher -

Google reveals how it keeps the Play Store 2019-04-01 07:30:33If you're only downloading apps from the Play Store, you're safe, says Google.

Planet Hollywood owner suffers major user data breach 2019-04-01 07:00:23Details on millions of credit cards stolen.

Public cloud adoption – which approach is right 2019-04-01 06:30:38As uncertainty remains the mood of Britain, companies are prioritising digital transformation programmes to ensure continued growth.

Dev Pro

Microsoft Edge Chromium Browser Available for Testing 2019-04-08 13:39:00Microsoft takes another step in their continuing trend of delivering products and services aimed at a heterogeneous enterprise. This time it is Micros

Internal Google Panel to Vet AI Projects Packed 2019-04-08 11:47:00Google has been at the center of a widening public debate over how automated systems might disadvantage vulnerable groups or lead to large-scale

xMatters Incident Management Tool Adds Stackdriver Integration 2019-04-07 07:16:00xMatters' integration with Google Cloud Stackdriver automates incident management for DevOps.

Defining Digital Transformation at Cloud Foundry Summit 2019-04-05 21:46:00ITPro Today was in Philadelphia this week to attend the Cloud Foundry North American Summit. In this video, we take you on the show floor and seek out

Fertility Database Relies on Blockchain for Security 2019-04-05 15:37:00FRTYL is trying to put families' minds at ease through the use of blockchain for security.

Facebook Found to Host Cybercriminal Groups Trading Stolen 2019-04-05 13:53:00Facebook Inc. housed dozens of cybercriminal groups that set up shop on the platform as online marketplaces to sell a variety of illegal services, suc

G Suites' Core App GMail Launched 15 Years 2019-04-05 12:56:00The cloud-based email service has become the core element of Google's G Suite productivity suite, and although it still lags behind competitors for k

Microsoft Vows to Focus on Gender Harassment Amid 2019-04-05 12:04:00Microsoft Corp.’s top executives pledged to discuss diversity and harassment issues at monthly employee meetings after complaints about sexual m

Google Scraps New AI Ethics Council After Staff, 2019-04-05 11:59:00“It’s become clear that in the current environment, ATEAC can’t function as we wanted,” Google said Thursday in a statement. &

Hannover Messe Provides Preview of Industrial AR’s Promise 2019-04-05 11:32:00Augmented reality was a star of Hannover Messe. But adoption of industrial AR will likely be first limited to defined use cases.

5 Questions with Google Cloud Director of Learning 2019-04-05 11:17:00Google cloud certifications offer IT pros the ability to prepare for the evolving job market, director, Google Cloud Learning and Enablement, Rochana

Amazon Cloud Storage Dilemma Exposed in Facebook's Latest 2019-04-04 13:35:00The trove in question included 540 million pieces of information, such as identification numbers, comments, reactions and account names, that had been

TechRadar: Internet news

The best Sky TV deals, packages and Sky 2019-04-09 07:06:22Save money on the latest Sky packages as we examine the latest deals including Sky Q boxes.

Amazon has slashed prices on Samsung Note 8 2019-04-09 07:01:24Get a superb SIM-free Samsung this spring - we've never seen Note 9 deals as cheap as they are now at Amazon.

AMD Ryzen CPUs continue to dominate Intel chips, 2019-04-09 06:53:58AMD actually holds an almost 70% processor market share, going by the figures from one retailer.

Revolutionary Algorithmic Lace bra wins the 2019 Lexus 2019-04-09 06:46:23Other finalists include a device for harvesting waste energy from jet engines, and a material made from desert sand.

Why you need to make the right call 2019-04-09 06:30:22Aptean's James Wood explains that although call centres have a bad reputation among customers, it doesn't have to be that way.

The Honor 20 Lite could have three rear 2019-04-09 06:28:10A report about the Honor 20 Lite suggests it could have cameras that are almost as good as the Huawei P30's.

Openreach connects 1.2m properties to FTTP 2019-04-09 06:21:26BT-owned Openreach adds 14,000 premises every week

The 10 best DSLRs you can buy in 2019-04-09 06:13:26Buying a DSLR can be a daunting task, but you'll be on the way to choosing the right camera with our expert guide.

CorelDRAW Graphics Suite 2019 offers hobbyists and professionals 2019-04-09 06:06:48A great image editing suite for hobbyists and pros alike.

Microsoft opens a plugin store for the new 2019-04-09 06:06:41The new store already has 118 extensions available to download, and many more are likely to arrive soon.

The 10 best mirrorless cameras in 2019 2019-04-09 06:04:12Coming in all shapes and sizes, our expert guide will help you choose the best mirrorless camera for you.

The 10 best 4K cameras in UAE for 2019-04-09 05:57:16Looking for a camera that's just as at home shooting 4K video as it is stills? Here are our picks to suit a range of budgets.

Enterprise – TechCrunch

WeWork acquires Managed By Q 2019-04-03 13:24:26Managed By Q, the office management platform based out of New York, has today been acquired by The We Company, formerly known as WeWork. Financial ter

Google Drive adds workflow integrations with DocuSign, K2 2019-04-03 12:31:34Google today announced a few new workflow integrations for its Drive file storage service that’ll bring to the service support for some features

Torch takes $10M to teach empathy to executives 2019-04-03 10:11:53When everyone always tells you “yes,” you can become a monster. Leaders especially need honest feedback to grow. “If you look at ric

Rippling raises $45M at $270M to be the 2019-04-03 09:18:02Parker Conrad’s last startup, Zenefits, drowned in busy work. Now with Rippling, he wants to boil that ocean. Instead of trying to nail one thin

Okta unveils $50M in-house venture capital fund 2019-04-03 09:00:49Okta Ventures wants to fund the next generation of identity, security and privacy startups.

Enterprise blockchain startup Offchain Labs scores $3.7M seed 2019-04-03 09:00:30Two of the issues limiting blockchain adoption in the enterprise has been lack of scalability and privacy. Offchain Labs, a startup that spun out of r

Onfido, which verifies IDs using AI, nabs $50M 2019-04-03 08:10:31Security breaches, where malicious hackers obtain snippets of information that then get used to impersonate individuals in order to gain access to ind

Container security startup Aqua lands $62M Series C 2019-04-03 06:20:27Aqua Security, a startup that helps customers launch containers securely, announced a $62 million Series C investment today led by Insight Partners. E

How to handle dark data compliance risk at 2019-04-02 15:00:51Slack and other consumer-grade productivity tools have been taking off in workplaces large and small — and data governance hasn’t caught u

Densify announces new tool to optimize container management 2019-04-02 11:52:47Densify, a Toronto company that helps customers optimize their cloud resources to control usage and spending, announced a new tool today specifically

FireHydrant lands $1.5M seed investment to bring order 2019-04-02 10:00:46FireHydrant, an NYC startup, wants to help companies recover from IT disasters more quickly, and understand why they happened — with the goal of

Pixeom raises $15M for its software-defined edge computing 2019-04-02 09:30:19Pixeom, a startup that offers a software-defined edge computing platform to enterprises, today announced that it has raised a $15 million funding roun

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.