• Follow us


How Arrivo Got Colorado to Back a Wild-Eyed Highway Scheme

The proposals that Brogan BamBrogan and Andrew Liu showed Shailen Bhatt promised a fanciful world: highways moving ten times more vehicles than they do now. Shipments zipping throughout the Denver area at 200 miles per hour. People getting from their homes to the airport gate in minutes. A new mode of transportation, moving people in numbers and speed far beyond what any metro system in the world accomplishes today. “The end of traffic,” they called it.

This was August 2017, when BamBrogan and Liu, cofounders of futuristic transportation company Arrivo, pitched Bhatt, then the executive director of the Colorado Department of Transportation, on their ambitious vision. They hoped to enter a partnership with the governing body on their “inspired by the Hyperloop concept.”

Arrivo’s pitch promised its technology would propel both specifically designed pods and people’s personal cars on sleds at hundreds of miles an hour, running along the medians of existing highways. Based on “linear-electric motors and magnetic levitation,” it would cost about the same to use as public transit or a toll road.

Bhatt says he was less captivated by their vision than their goal of building a proof-of-concept test track in Colorado, which would mean jobs for the state. In a follow-up letter sent to the Arrivo cofounders, which WIRED obtained along with Arrivo’s pitch materials and other documents through a public records request, he said he shared an Arrivo document with then-governor’s John Hickenlooper’s office. He assured BamBrogan and Liu that their interest in partnering with Colorado “has interest at the highest level.”

On November 14, the Colorado DOT, Arrivo, and the E-470 Public Highway Authority announced a partnership to build a test track along E-470, the toll interstate that runs through the western Denver suburbs and connects to Denver International Airport. They would hire up to 200 employees and conduct feasibility studies in exchange for $267,000 in performance-based incentives from the Colorado Office of Economic Development. Along with renderings of the system, Arrivo released a video of Bhatt and BamBrogan admiring classic cars and talking about transportation technology. In a press release announcing the deal, BamBrogan boasted, “Arrivo will end traffic and futureproof regional mobility.”

It didn’t quite work out that way. At the end of 2018, Arrivo shut down due to a lack of funding. Construction on the test track, originally slated to begin in the first quarter of 2018, never broke ground. Arrivo never completed its feasibility study. There is no evidence the company ever completed a proof of concept at any scale. BamBrogan did not respond to an interview request, and attempts to reach Liu were unsuccessful.

The speedy demise of Arrivo and its promised transportation system makes one wonder what CDOT saw in a company without any clear evidence it could deliver on outrageous promises. And it raises the larger questions of how much credibility future-focused mobility companies get by partnering with governments—even if their ideas amount to little more than glossy marketing brochures—and what those governments hope to gain in the process.

Indeed, Arrivo’s pitch to CDOT included claims that Yonah Freemark, a PhD candidate in urban studies at MIT and founder of the influential website The Transport Politic, calls “very unrealistic.” In one presentation, proposing a connection to the Denver airport, Arrivo promised its “Super Metro” people-mover, which could fit 20 or 30 passengers, would transport 72,000 to 108,000 people per hour. That’s three to four times the peak capacity of New York’s L subway train, one of the busiest in the system.

Arrivo’s pitch promised its technology would propel both specifically designed pods and people’s personal cars on sleds at hundreds of miles an hour, running along the medians of existing highways.


In a press release announcing Arrivo's deal with Colorado, Brogan BamBrogan boasted, “Arrivo will end traffic and futureproof regional mobility.”


Meanwhile, Denver already has a good airport connector. In his book Trains, Buses, People, transportation expert Christof Spieler named the A line one of the best commuter rail lines in the country, noting it is the only such system in the country that runs every 15 minutes, seven days a week. (Spieler is, though, critical of Denver’s transit network in general.)

“We weren’t necessarily invested in the transformative piece of their technology,” says CDOT spokesperson Amy Ford. Rather, the agency wanted to investigate what the governance structure could look like should the technology come to fruition, she says. CDOT and Arrivo paid for their own studies with the consultant firm Aecom, Arrivo cofounder Liu’s previous employer. Ford says CDOT spent $250,000 on this study, which will cover not just Arrivo but other potential hyperloop and future mobility technologies. Ford described the expense as worthwhile regardless of Arrivo’s existence, and as a tiny portion of the department’s $1.4 billion annual budget. “If this was a 100-step process, we were at step, like, three,” Ford says.

Although Bhatt no longer works for CDOT, he says it will take big ideas to solve Colorado’s congestion challenges. Ten years ago, he wouldn’t have predicted app-based car services would transform urban transportation. Two years ago, he wouldn’t have guessed e-scooters would flood urban areas. Instead of trying to predict what will or won’t work, Bhatt says his role as a government official was to ask, “How do we make sure we are creating an environment where companies feel like they can come and do business?”

The Arrivo partnership fit into CDOT’s RoadX program, which encourages public-private partnerships to address serious congestion and a booming population. It’s all about big ideas. “We've been flying to the moon since the 1960s,” the RoadX web site beckons, “the time has come for transportation on this planet to make a giant leap.”

RoadX is perhaps the most coordinated effort by any state to court futuristic transportation companies, but it’s part of a larger trend. Elon Musk’s Boring Company has engaged, to varying degrees, with Chicago to build a tunnel from The Loop to O’Hare Airport (although that project is in serious jeopardy due to shifting political winds), two tunnels in LA (one of which was cancelled), and a Washington, D.C. to Baltimore connector. Virgin Hyperloop One, BamBrogan’s former employer, named CDOT among the 10 winners of a “Global Challenge” to propose feasible routes in welcoming places.

But for more traditional transportation experts, this shoot-for-the-moon mindset is indicative of this country’s mobility issues: While they like the idea of maglev trains and supersonic tubes, American cities often fail to get the basics of transportation planning right, like running reliable bus and rail service.

“Americans are constantly hoping for what's next, dreaming of some great new invention that will save them from whatever ills they currently experience,” says Freemark. “It's not surprising that the Arrivo videos are filled with scenes of people's daily lives—work, soccer, the beach—because it's meant to simply be placed on top of whatever we already have, yet somehow instantly make everything better. In that way, it's no surprise at all that political officials would find it appealing.”

One of the very reasons governments may find these futuristic options so attractive is they don’t yet know precisely how they will work, so they can fit any vision desirable. They’re essentially a blank slate, on which every improvement can be imagined and all downsides or skepticism assumed away. And who doesn’t want to be at the vanguard of innovation?

Arrivo’s flop hasn’t stopped Colorado from pursuing a shiny future. RoadX is moving ahead with its partnership with Virgin Hyperloop One. It’s hoping to build a pilot tube between the city of Greeley and the airport about 40 miles to the south, and possibly build an entire network across the state.

Once its feasibility study is completed, Ford says CDOT might have a clearer picture of the regulatory and other hurdles that need to be cleared. But if the country’s inability to construct high-speed rail—not to mention run conventional rail networks—is any indication, that will just be the beginning of what it takes to make real hyperloop or whatever idea comes next. Or, as Ford indicated, there are still 97 steps to go.

More Great WIRED StoriesParents, here’s how to make YouTube Kids saferInvisible malware can lurk in “bare metal” cloud serversThe best photo of birds fighting over food you'll ever seeWhy four-panel comics now dominate our screensHow a DIY Tesla mechanic resurrects flooded electric cars👀 Looking for the latest gadgets? Check out our latest buying guides and best deals all year round📩 Hungry for even more deep dives on your next favorite topic? Sign up for the Backchannel newsletterRead More

Leave A Comment

More News


Waymo’s Move to Sell Lidar Units Is a 2019-03-06 14:47:20The shift to sell its technology to robotics and security companies is an indication that Waymo isn’t placing all its bets on self-driving cars.

Mercedes Remakes the Minivan as an All-Electric Luxury 2019-03-05 03:30:00The German automaker’s MPV has room for eight, 249 miles of range, and makes the kiddie karter look good.

How Amazon Taught the Echo Auto to Hear 2019-03-04 07:00:00Start with a sort of crash test dummy that has creepily realistic human ears, then add a bunch of road noise. Repeat.

Tesla’s $35,000 Model 3 Arrives and More Cars 2019-03-03 09:00:00Elon Musk hits a milestone and gets in trouble with the SEC, Lyft files for its IPO, cities investigate congestion pricing, and more.

How Arrivo Got Colorado to Back a Wild-Eyed 2019-03-02 07:00:00Brogan BamBrogan's company promised Colorado a hyperloop-inspired transportation, then shut down.

Lyft’s IPO Filing Shows Ridership Is Surging—So Are 2019-03-01 17:50:36Uber's recent stumbles have helped Lyft surge ahead in terms of revenue, but its costs are growing, too.

The Age of Congestion Pricing May Finally Be 2019-02-28 19:19:06Some US cities might start charging extra to drive on crowded, busy roads.

Tesla’s Model 3 Is Now Selling for $35,000 2019-02-28 18:58:10Elon Musk’s automaker is also introducing a slightly more capable version of the car, moving its sales process online, and shuttering many of it

Electric Polestar 2 Is a Mass-Market Tesla Model 2019-02-27 19:01:29Volvo's electric- and performance-focused brand eschews the SUV trend with the fastback Polestar 2.

Elon Musk’s Latest Tweets Could Land Him in 2019-02-25 22:46:06The SEC has asked a judge to hold the Tesla CEO in contempt of court, but even that didn't stop Musk's tweeting.

Trouble Brews Anew at Tesla, Plus More Car 2019-02-24 09:00:00The Tesla Model 3 loses its *Consumer Reports* recommended status, we drive Hyundai’s hydrogen-powered SUV, and more.

Hyundai Nexo Review: The Hydrogen Fuel Cell-Powered Electric 2019-02-22 09:00:00Hyundai has made an excellent car, but that may not be enough to overcome the difficulties of driving on hydrogen.

Automotive News Breaking

Tesla will drop 'misleading' marketing in Germany touting 2019-03-07 08:05:51Tesla agreed to get rid of fuel-savings claims for its Model 3 sedan in Germany that a fair-competition watchdog said are misleading.  

Ghosn-led companies donated to exec's children's school 2019-03-07 08:01:53The Renault-Nissan alliance and Ghosn's family are listed as donors by the American School in Paris, which has a "Ghosn room."

The mastermind behind Ghosn's dramatic bail release and 2019-03-07 07:50:53Carlos Ghosn’s bet on a new team of lawyers paid off this week, thanks to a legal ace who orchestrated his release on bail from a Tokyo jail aft

Continental says AV revenues won't be significant until 2019-03-07 07:24:51Continental CEO Elmar Degenhart said that the autonomous vehicle market "will be driven mainly by assistance systems. Significant revenues will

Tesla says it plans to boost charger network 2019-03-07 06:52:08Charging times for Tesla vehicles will drop to around 15 minutes, the company said on its blog. After rolling out in North America, the technolog

A chaotic market for one sensor stalls self-driving 2019-03-06 16:17:46Automakers and technology companies racing to develop self-driving vehicles are running into a problem: cars that can think are no good without afford

U.S. extends time for divestment from sanctioned Russian 2019-03-06 16:03:43The U.S. Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control said in a statement that it would allow investors and businesses until July 6 to cut ties with G

New Chrysler Pacifica ad: Perception of minivan ownership 2019-03-06 15:22:09The new ad campaign, featuring actor Jamie Foxx, launched this week as sales of the minivan got off to a slow start this year.

Last Chevrolet Cruze in Ohio built amid GM 2019-03-06 15:19:57Workers posted photos of the final Cruze making its way down the assembly line on social media. It came off the line around 3 p.m., a GM spokesman sai

Ghosn girds for the legal fight of his 2019-03-06 14:23:14Free after 108 days of spartan prison conditions, Ghosn’s first stop was to his lawyer’s office. He changed into a suit, the uniform of th

Ford investigating possible problems with fuel economy, emissions 2019-02-21 17:04:03Ford has been investigating concerns raised by employees that incorrect calculations were used to translate test results into the mileage and emission

Visteon Q4 net income rose 72%, shares climb 2019-02-21 15:54:41Despite industry headwinds, Visteon posted $43 million in fourth-quarter net income and forecast continued strong results for 2019.

All Motor Trend Stories RSS

Production Maserati Alfieri Will Debut in Geneva Next 2019-03-07 08:00:56Back in July, Maserati and Alfa Romeo boss Tim Kuniskis told us the Alfieri concept would be put into production as part of a plan to overha

2019 Chevrolet Blazer RS First Test: The Camaro 2019-03-07 04:00:37I have to imagine it wasn’t supposed to be this way. There have been rumblings from inside Chevrolet for years that the automaker was planning a

Next-Gen Honda Civic Type R Will Most Likely 2019-03-06 18:45:03Earlier this week, Honda announced an accelerated electrification strategy in Europe. Instead of electrified vehicles making up two-thirds of sales&nb

Best Cars of the 2019 Geneva Motor Show: 2019-03-06 18:30:45Every year, you can count on the Geneva International Motor Show to deliver the latest and greatest supercars and hypercars, along with a mix of exclu

Ford Adds 2020 F-600 Super Duty to its 2019-03-06 16:45:08After redesigning the F-150 for 2015 and the Super Duty for 2017, Ford gave its best-seller a mid-cycle refresh for 2018. Then, early l

Forbidden Fruit Cars of the 2019 Geneva Motor 2019-03-06 16:26:45The Geneva Motor Show is a feast for the eyes, not only in terms of the improbably expensive hypercars from brands you’ve never heard of, but al

McLaren Adding a Grand Tourer to the Lineup 2019-03-06 16:00:40McLaren is entering new territory with a $200,000 grand tourer planned for those who want a performance luxury car that is comfortable for a weekend g

SsangYong Delaying U.S. Launch 2019-03-06 15:15:41South Korean automaker SsangYong Motor has paused plans to launch its crossover-laden lineup in the U.S. market—which had been forecast for 2020

Here’s What It’s Like to Sit Inside the 2019-03-06 14:15:31There I was, halfway through an interview with the CEO of Aston Martin, Andy Palmer, and it’s late in the day on the second day of the Geneva mo

Ousted Nissan Boss Ghosn Leaves Japan Jail After 2019-03-06 13:30:04Ousted Nissan boss Carlos Ghosn walked out of a Tokyo prison on a $9 million bail on Wednesday, slipping past reporters in a face mask and m

2020 Porsche 911 Turbo 992 Leaks on Instagram 2019-02-21 17:53:32Porsche owner and enthusiast Todd Schleicher has posted what could be the first public images of the 992-generation 2020 Porsche 911 Turbo on his Inst

Spied! Chevrolet Caught Testing a Small Fleet of 2019-02-21 16:26:32Earlier this month, we caught yet another mid-engine Corvette prototype out testing on public roads. Interestingly, it wasn’t running around in

Automotive news - from

UK govt has "lost its way" as Brexit 2019-03-07 07:54:00Britain's Road Haulage Association (RHA) says it is "deeply concerned at the complete and utter lack of clarity," which remains with regards to bor

West European car market down 1.6% in February 2019-03-07 07:24:00West European car registrations fell 1.6% year-on-year in February, according to data released by LMC Automotive. However, it also said the annualised

Now Toyota threatens to leave UK if Brexit 2019-03-07 07:07:00Toyota Motor has suggested it could end UK production as early as 2023 if the country leaves the European Union without a deal on the terms of it

Mitsubishi Electric starts Czech Republic plant build 2019-03-07 06:59:00Mitsubishi Electric Corporation says it will start construction of a new plant on the premises of its subsidiary, Mitsubishi Electric Automotive

US sales for Polestar 2 threatened by trade 2019-03-07 06:58:00The Geely/Volvo Cars owned Polestar brand has warned that the launch of its new fully electric model in the US could be jeopardised by trade tari

Hyundai axes oldest Chinese assembly plant 2019-03-07 06:40:00Hyundai will close its oldest plant in China as early as next month due to plummeting sales in the world's biggest market, South Korean media reporte

Japan sales rise in February 2019-03-07 04:17:00Japan's new vehicle market edged up by 1.2% to 479,428 units in February from weak year-earlier sales of 473,876 units, according to registration dat

OECD report sees global economic growth slowing 2019-03-07 04:13:00The global economy is slowing and major risks persist, with growth weakening much more than expected in Europe, according to the OECD's latest econom

UK light commercials sales up so far in 2019-03-06 09:11:00The UK new light commercial vehicle (LCV) market remained "stable" in February, with year-on-year demand growing by 1.8%, according to the latest da

Schaeffler cuts 900 jobs as EV shift gathers 2019-03-06 08:51:00Schaeffler's Automotive OEM division is to axe 900 jobs and "consolidate" five European plants as it reacts to the shift from internal combustion e

Australian sales dip in February 2019-03-06 07:54:00Australia's Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries (FCAI) reported sales of 87,102 new vehicles during February 2019 down 9.3% year-on-year.

Thailand to cut excise taxes on local EVs, 2019-03-06 06:32:00The Thai government this week agreed to suspend the local excise tax on battery-powered electric vehicles (BEVs) for a period of three years to help e

High Gear Media Network Feed

Maserati Alfieri locked in for 2020 Geneva auto 2019-03-07 07:00:00Maserati's Alfieri sports car will be shown at the 2020 Geneva International Motor Show but won't reach showrooms until 2021 or 2022. The informatio

McLaren 720S Spider by MSO accentuates its aero 2019-03-07 06:00:00It's pretty much common practice these days to see McLaren Special Operations flex its creativity to show off the possibilities within the department

2022 BMW iNext spy shots 2019-03-07 02:00:00BMW is working on a technological flagship code-named the iNext, which the automaker previewed last September with the Vision iNext concept and has si

2020 Mercedes-Benz CLA Shooting Brake is forbidden fruit 2019-03-06 17:00:00Americans still aren't too keen on wagon body styles, and that likely makes the 2020 Mercedes-Benz CLA Shooting Brake off limits stateside. However,

Updated Land Rover Range Rover Sentinel adds power 2019-03-06 16:00:00Flashback to 2015 and recall Jaguar-Land Rover's Special Vehicle Operations revealed an armored version of the swanky Range Rover with the Sentinel b

Fiat Concept Centoventi imagines snap-together customization 2019-03-06 15:00:00Fiat turns 120 years old this year, and to celebrate, the brand introduced the Concept Centoventi at the 2019 Geneva International Motor Show. The con

Goodyear creates concept tires that can act as 2019-03-06 14:00:00If the future does, in fact, include flying cars as a new sort of transportation method, it's best to have equipment that can handle both roads and f

2020 Hyundai Sonata ready to shine brightly 2019-03-06 13:00:00The Hyundai Sonata received wide praise for its bold styling when it was redesigned for 2010. In 2016, that fanfare retreated when it received a rathe

Koenigsegg Jesko deep dive: 7 clutches, 1,600 hp, 2019-03-06 11:45:00When you're developing a replacement for the fastest car on the planet, a typical update isn't going to cut the mustard. Fortunately, that wasn't a

Gordon Murray's McLaren F1 successor to boast V-12 2019-03-06 11:32:00Gordon Murray gave the world the McLaren F1 in the 1990s as its designer. After operating his design business for years, Murray formed his own car com

Aston Martin Vanquish, Alfa Romeo Tonale, Ruf GT: 2019-03-06 11:00:00Aston Martin surprised audiences at this week's 2019 Geneva International Motor Show with the reveal of not one but two mid-engine cars. One of them

Hyundai's latest app turns a smartphone into your 2019-03-06 10:00:00Future Hyundai cars won't require a key at all. The automaker has announced a new digital key that turns an owner's smartphone into a key to lock/un

Featured Articles

Subaru Impreza review 2019-03-07 07:54:23 For  Strong safety credentials Four-wheel-drive grip Long list of equipment Our Rating  3

Tesla unveils its 250kW V3 Supercharging system 2019-03-07 06:17:06 Luke Wilkinson 2019-03-07 11:19 Tesla has released its latest charging system, capable of delivering 75 miles of range in 5 minut

SEAT Tarraco review 2019-03-07 04:55:20 For  Good to drive Stylish looks Smart interior Our Rating  4 Against 

Gumpert Nathalie debuts at Geneva 2019-03-06 11:53:57 Luke Wilkinson 2019-03-06 16:50 Gumpert unwrapped the world’s first methanol-electric supercar at Geneva this year, with a

Current BMW i3 to get revamp rather than 2019-03-06 11:38:08 John McIlroy 2019-03-06 16:40 The BMW i3 is entering its seventh year of production, but the electric car will continue to be pro

BMW M division to use i electric car 2019-03-06 11:25:33 John McIlroy 2019-03-06 16:25 Future BMW M cars could use tech developed by the firm's i electrification team to boost performan

Audi set to cut its model range 2019-03-06 10:57:22 Jonathan Burn 2019-03-06 16:00 The cost of investing in electric vehicles and autonomous tech means Audi is set to reduce its mod

Special edition Cupra Ateca unveiled at Geneva 2019-03-06 09:50:21 Luke Wilkinson 2019-03-06 14:55 Available in limited numbers later this year, the special edition Cupra Ateca features a handful

De Tomaso and Apollo make unconventional Geneva appearances 2019-03-06 09:49:08 Luke Wilkinson 2019-03-06 14:55 Italian supercar brand De Tomaso attempted to upstage the Geneva show by driving around in a camo

Peugeot says level 4 autonomous cars would mean 2019-03-06 09:35:02 Alex Ingram 2019-03-06 14:40 Level 3 autonomy is the limit for Peugeot as its CEO reveals a £13,000 price premium would be

“The new VW Group is letting its other 2019-03-06 08:20:32 Steve Fowler 2019-03-06 13:20 SEAT’s position as a technology leader wouldn’t have happened under previous VW managem

New McLaren 720S Spider by MSO debuts tri-tone 2019-03-06 07:15:17 Luke Wilkinson 2019-03-06 13:00 McLaren Special Operations showcases customised 720S Spider at Geneva, featuring a tri-tone paint

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.