• Follow us

Men

The Staff of Music is Long, But It Bends Towards Harmony - The Good Men Project

—“To those who think that mash-ups and sampling started with YouTube or a DJ’s turntables, it might be shocking to find that musicians have been borrowing—extensively borrowing, consciously and unconsciously—from each other since music itself began,” write James Boyle and Jennifer Jenkins, two superhero academics have taken on the subject of music and creativity in a new graphic novel. Meticulously researched and incredibly entertaining, the book explores 2,000 years of musical history, from Plato’s admonition that “musical innovation is full of danger to the whole state” to the recent “Blurred Lines” case – and everything in between.

Photo credit: Creative Commons Blog

Theft! A History of Music is the newest comic from Jenkins and Boyle, the team behind the 2006 fair use comic Bound by Law. Theft was written in collaboration with the late illustrator and academic Keith Aoki; Boyle and Jenkins developed the graphic designs that were illustrated and inked by Ian Akin and Brian Garvey. The book is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 and is available on the website of the Duke Center for the Study of the Public Domain.

In the book’s afterword, you write that you thought you were “done with comic books.” Why this one, and why now? How did the process of writing this book, which took ten years, differ from your previous comic, “Bound by Law?” Why did you decide to take on music as your next subject?

Bound By Law had success far beyond our expectations because it met a need – it explained fair use to a generation of creators and reusers of culture who found the language of copyright law mystifying and felt thwarted by the “permissions culture” of today, which presumes that permissions and fees must be attached to even the tiniest piece of creative culture.

We thought the same was true of music – particularly the permissions culture point. But when we came to write the book we saw that it had to roam much further, through the history of attempts to regulate musical borrowing – whether on grounds of philosophy, religion, race, or property rights. We saw common themes in all of those, common relationships between technology, incentives, law and the fire of sympathetic inspiration, which is impatient with barriers – whether it was a generation of white teenagers being inspired by African American rhythm and blues, or a church composer taking from the songs of the troubadours. As for the ten years it took us to finish, that gets to the pledge we made to our dear departed colleague, Keith Aoki.

Photo credit: Creative Commons Blog

In some “superhero” type scenes, your protagonists struggle with the push and pull between power and control vs freedom, with alter-egos employed to demonstrate the impossibility of the decision. How do you, as academics and authors, reconcile the tension between these two forces?

We don’t think that the forces can ever be reconciled once and for all; they are dynamic tensions that actually drive the art. The important thing is to understand that this is a dynamic balance, not a simple equation where more control means more incentives and thus more art.

Jamie still remembers the first conversations with Larry Lessig, Hal Abelson and others about why we needed Creative Commons – we asked the Copyright office how creators could choose to share, to make their material freely available for others to use and build upon. Their answer was “we don’t provide that service.” That is missing a key part of the cultural dynamic – the fact that culture needs raw material on which to build. Creative Commons tried to deal with one aspect of that, namely the sharing commons. But we understood very well that some of that raw material needs to be there because law doesn’t reach it in the first place. For example, E=MC2 or the alphabet aren’t “owned” and if they were you would get less creativity, not more. Yet that does not mean freedom is always the answer. We want artists and composers to have rights over their work and to receive the compensation and attribution they richly deserve. That is in their, and our, interests. But it is also in their interests to have the freedoms to build on the past in interstitial ways that prior musical generations took for granted!

Photo credit: Creative Commons Blog

Something I found particularly compelling about the book is the complicated nature of many of the artists’ copyright disputes juxtaposed with lighthearted illustrations and narrative. For example, you discuss a number of surprising stories from the 20th Century, like the clampdown on the kind of sampling in early Public Enemy (the court decision announcing “get a license or do not sample”) or the case finding George Harrison liable for “subconscious” copying. You also include more distant history about Bach, Gutenberg, and even Plato in ways that are easy to understand and often irreverent. What was it like to turn court cases and history into comics? How did you employ storytelling tropes to craft a narrative out of 2000 years of scholarship and history?

Each domain of creativity – from music to comics – has its own dynamics. As academics, fond of long, carefully constructed arguments, we found it a wonderful challenge to fit complex and multifaceted ideas into a comic panel, a picture and a short speech bubble! But designing each of those panels was what made the art so truly satisfying – it was a rush, a creative high. As for law, it can be the subject of both art and humour – look at what Shakespeare and Dickens do with it! The question for us here was whether we could be technically faithful to the details and nuances – this is academic research with references behind every assertion, but it is also an attempt to capture a “conversation” that has been going on for hundreds of years, and do so fairly.

Photo credit: Creative Commons Blog

Even a casual reader will notice that the book is well researched. How did you do the research? How did you decide on the narrative structure, from the invention of notation to “Blurred Lines?” What primary sources did you draw on, and how did you do it collaboratively?

Again, there is so much to tell. We worked with composers and musicologists – our colleague, Dr. Anthony Kelley of the Duke music department bears much of the credit there. We taught classes made up of half law students and half composers and asked each group to explain the lines that the other group drew around “allowed” and “forbidden” creativity. We scoured the great books about musical history and borrowing – there are many. We drew on the legal scholars who have touched on this debate – Mike Carroll, another person on the CC founding board has written several of the most important law review articles on the subject. And above all, we listened to how music has been influenced and changed over time.

As for the structure, it emerged out of the chaos of our desire to tell the story and our panic that we wouldn’t be able to do so in a way that showed how fascinating it is. The readers of the book will be the best judge of whether we succeeded.

Photo credit: Creative Commons Blog

The book ends with a question – what will music production and rights look like going forward? How will musicians find their way in the 21st century? What do you think is the future of music?

We see several possible futures. Frankly, if we go on our current path – with the permissions culture extending legal claims to the atomic level of musical creativity – then we think that the future will be poorly served. We say in the book that we wouldn’t have got jazz, rock and roll, soul or the blues if we had used the rules we have today. Those musical forms would simply have been made impossible. It is a horrifying thought to think of that dynamic denying us the next great musical form. But we also see a reaction against that cultural sclerosis. We wanted this book to provide the raw material, the balanced information, that helps us decide as a culture which line we wish to go down.

Watch a three minute video about the book below:—[embedded content]

[embedded content]

This post was previously published on www.creativecommons.org and is republished here under a Creative Commons license CC BY-ND 4.0.

What’s your take? Comment below or write a response and submit to us your own point of view or reaction here at the red box, below, which links to our submissions portal.

submit to Good Men Project

submit to Good Men Project

◊♦◊

Sign up for our Writing Prompts email to receive writing inspiration in your inbox twice per week.

If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member, today.

All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.

A $50 annual membership gives you an all-access pass. You can be a part of every call, group, class, and community.A $25 annual membership gives you access to one class, one Social Interest group, and our online communities.A $12 annual membership gives you access to our Friday calls with the publisher, our online community.

Register New Account

Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.

◊♦◊

Get the best stories from The Good Men Project delivered straight to your inbox, here.

Photo credit: Istockphoto.com

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

Acquire

This duffel bag was once issued to the 2019-07-02 06:37:13This duffel isn't just a handsome lookin' fella, it's got quite a resume that should make it an easy sell for anyone who wants a solid travel bag.

Vertex releases a DLC coated version of its 2019-07-02 06:22:21Vertex's recently revived watch lineup grows this summer with a new version of their MP45 chronograph in a DLC-coated case. Just like its silver-case

Feit's new caps keep it low profile and 2019-07-02 06:05:07Feit is updating its range of caps with a soft and breathable organic cotton for the summer. Made in Japan in small quantities, these six-panel baseba

Status combines high-quality audio and an accessible price 2019-07-02 03:00:00Status Audio is launching two new Bluetooth headphones with audiophile-grade sound and a price point that won't do too much damage to your wallet. Th

Blancpain adds a touch of blue to the 2019-07-01 18:15:32Blancpain's contribution to this year's Only Watch auction comes in the form of a throwback to the Fifty Fathoms Barakuda, which has its hands and m

Singer's Track 1 chronograph gets a Damascus steel 2019-07-01 16:41:53Singer Reimagined's Track 1 chronograph is getting a unique case to match its unique movement. The Only Watch edition of the Track 1 will feature a 4

Tudor reveals a Black Bay in ceramic for 2019-07-01 16:17:53Tudor's contribution to the 2019 Only Watch auction is a blacked-out version of their popular Black Bay timepiece. The tonal design swaps out the 41m

Defakto grows its minimalist watch collection with the 2019-07-01 05:43:07Defakto might not be a watch brand that's on your radar, but if you enjoy a good design watch then you definitely should give their collection a look

Jays launches its first pair of true wireless 2019-07-01 03:00:00It looks like there's a bit of a war brewing between audio companies fighting to outdo Apple's AirPods when it comes to battery life. The latest com

Butterscotch LB whips up a limited edition of 2019-07-01 03:00:00Rolling Dub Trio's Stan boot isn't your average pair of Chelseas. Long Beach retailer Butterscotch LB commissioned Rolling Dub Trio to craft an excl

Paul Smith launches a new set of suitcases 2019-07-01 03:00:00Paul Smith and Globe-Trotter strike up a partnership once again with a new set of suitcases inspired by the colors of Smith's signature stripes. Avai

Simon Crompton's Sartorial Travel Guide highlights some of 2019-07-01 03:00:00Author Simon Crompton highlights some of his favorite independent menswear retailers across the globe in a new travel guide for style-conscious jet-se

The Good Men Project

What My Soul Wants of Me 2019-07-03 14:00:34None of this matters. Except maybe love. The post What My Soul Wants of Me appeared first on The Good Men Project.

10 Year Authentic Business Plan for Semi-Retirement 2019-07-03 13:30:45Creating true freedom by fulfilling your calling. The post 10 Year Authentic Business Plan for Semi-Retirement appeared first on The Good Men Project.

Dunking Over Darwin 2019-07-03 13:00:33Evolution and NBA Free Agency The post Dunking Over Darwin appeared first on The Good Men Project.

Paying Homage to My African American Family 2019-07-03 12:30:29Self-hatred is destroying us. The post Paying Homage to My African American Family appeared first on The Good Men Project.

What Paths Life Takes 2019-07-03 12:00:54Make it happen, let it happen, or somewhere in the middle? The post What Paths Life Takes appeared first on The Good Men Project.

What is Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) 2019-07-03 11:30:40How your eye movements can be therapeutic. The post What is Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) Therapy? appeared first on The Good M

Men Need Safe Places To Feel (Angry) 2019-07-03 11:00:46We’ve only ever seen anger used to hurt people. The post Men Need Safe Places To Feel (Angry) appeared first on The Good Men Project.

Understanding the Signs of Unhappiness 2019-07-03 10:30:32Often unhappiness can be a many-headed beast, perhaps impacting several aspects of your life. The post Understanding the Signs of Unhappiness appeared

Every Day Is Like Sunday 2019-07-03 10:00:09Researchers probably ignore Sundays, preferring to use their professional expertise by predicting election results wrongly instead. The post Every Day

4 Things I Have Discovered About Boys Since 2019-07-03 09:30:05Having a son is really all it's cracked up to be. The post 4 Things I Have Discovered About Boys Since Becoming a Mom to One appeared first on The Go

9 Certain Traits of Untrustworthy People 2019-07-03 09:00:26Trust is the glue of life---the foundational principle that holds all relationships. The post 9 Certain Traits of Untrustworthy People appeared first

Lost Pies and Lost Hope: A Father’s Struggle 2019-07-03 08:30:26The world is burned and all that is left is an empty pie tin. The post Lost Pies and Lost Hope: A Father’s Struggle appeared first on The Good M

Maxim - The Ultimate Guys

Women Share The Best Things Guys Can Do 2019-07-02 07:30:00Considering the number of dating apps out there, it's clear that there are a lot of first dates going on but more often than not, scoring a second da

Where to Eat, Stay and Play in the 2019-07-02 07:00:00By air and sea, via superyacht, private jet or the more prosaic cruise ship, the number of visitors alighting in the Bahamas is growing at a staggerin

5 Things We Know So Far About HBO's 2019-07-01 15:55:31Game of Thrones is gone, but definitely not forgotten. HBO is already filming one of the prequels in Northern Ireland, and of course that means s

'The Boil Boss' Is The Only Gadget You 2019-07-01 14:57:59Much like barbecue pit masters, seafood boil bosses are a competitive lot--purists who assert they’re the kings of the crawfish, shrimp or

Kevin Durant Left Warriors for Nets Because of 2019-07-01 14:41:36Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving are set to ink massive deals with the beleaguered Brooklyn Nets that could turn turn them into a bonafide NBA contender.

There's Now a Marathon in France Where Runners 2019-07-01 12:56:25If someone just told you there was a country that hosted a marathon featuring hydrating stations stocked with wine and cheese, you'd guess France, ri

Bentley GT Convertible Continental 'Number 1 Edition' Celebrates 2019-07-01 11:40:34Bentley is celebrating its centenary with 100 exclusive droptop Continental GTs that are oozing with supercar style.  Maxim recently test drove t

The Taco Bell Pop-Up Hotel Sold Out in 2019-07-01 11:15:35Taco Bell superfans, take note: The fast food chain beloved by stoners and late-night binge eaters alike is launching a Taco Bell-branded ho

How Mercedes-AMG Cigarette Boats Became the Ultimate High-Performance 2019-07-01 08:00:00As the graphite grey Cigarette Racing 41’ AMG Carbon Edition pulls away from the dock, captain Bud Lorow engages the engines. Shifting the cente

These Crushable Cocktails Will Liven Up Your Fourth 2019-07-01 07:00:00Summer brings light, bright, refreshing cocktails with ingredients that are are perfect for sipping by the pool, on the deck or anywhere else your cel

UFC's Dana White Confirms Fight Talks Between Justin 2019-06-30 14:07:48Even the fittest men slow down a little in their fifties. Reaction time isn't as good, and injuries don't heal as quickly. So if you're fifty-somet

Quentin Tarantino Goes Back to 1969 in New 2019-06-30 11:19:23Leonardo DiCaprio has an Oscar, never dates supermodels over 25, and he appears to still have all his own hair. He's doing just fine. In the new trai

WWDWWD

J.Hilburn Names New CEO 2019-07-01 19:19:17Dave DeFeo had been ceo of the Worth Collection for over a decade.

Wrangler Introduces Rooted Collection Sourced, Created in America 2019-06-28 11:24:29The line of jeans and T-shirts use cotton grown, milled, cut and sewn in the U.S.

Launchmetrics’ Numbers Support Strength of Paris, Italian Men’s 2019-06-28 11:04:32The firm analyzed media placements from the spring '19 season.

Ntwrk Receives Funding From Drake, Live Nation 2019-06-27 16:59:55The investment will also fund the launch of Ntwrk Presents, an event franchise.

Montblanc and Bape Team on Accessories Collection 2019-06-27 11:00:28The companies have launched a limited-edition co-branded collection of every day essentials at select Montblanc and Bape stores and online.

Men’s Spring 2020 Trend: Hang Loose 2019-06-27 00:01:25Men’s designers upped the volume for spring, featuring ponchos, baggy knitwear and looser cuts on suits and trousers in their collections.

Men’s Spring 2020 Trend: Graphic Art 2019-06-26 00:01:18For spring, many designers collaborated with artists to create works of art on the men’s runways, as bold prints and patterns stole the shows.

Retailers Embrace Feminine Side of Men’s Shows in 2019-06-25 01:05:42Dior, Louis Vuitton, Dries Van Noten, Casablanca, Nanushka were labels singled out by buyers.

Men’s Spring 2020 Trend: Pastel Path 2019-06-25 00:01:08Pastels made a strong showing on the men's runways in Europe this season. Bright shades shone through in loose tailoring, sportswear and more.

Willie Norris Makes Runway Debut at La Mama 2019-06-24 15:59:23Norris continued to push his pro-queer streetwear aesthetic with workwear-inspired looks made from deadstock fabric and repurposed clothing.

Eric Emanuel Opens First Solo Pop-up in NoLIta 2019-06-21 00:01:51The three-week shop will carry Emanuel’s signature mesh basketball shorts and a special Adidas Rivalry sneaker.

Eric Lawrence Debuts Odessa 1919 2019-06-21 00:01:19The former Anger designer has launched his second fashion venture, beginning with sterling silver-detailed Nike Air Force 1s available for preorder.

Breaking Muscle

Add New Disciplines to Your Training, Part 1: 2019-07-01 03:57:48You want to add yoga to your Olympic weightlifting or try martial arts with your powerlifting? Let's see what makes sense.   The question will

How to Put Your Body to Use for 2019-06-30 12:32:39People need more physical movement, more time in nature, and more connection. What if living life made you healthy? Just imagine a world where everyda

The Future of Video Replay for Weightlifting 2019-06-27 16:57:02In the IWF rules, four cameras are used, one near each referee and another behind the platform. Over two consecutive weekends in May I was able to of

The Bathroom Break Kettlebell Strength Plan 2019-06-27 14:42:56Following this daily plan, you can make tremendous strength and fitness gains while hardly investing any extra time. I drink a lot of water and coffe

Double Compound Movements 2019-06-27 13:37:52Double compound movements can be combined to create a fast and extremely powerful training effect. The ’70s and ’80s saw the birth of the

Do You Know What Your Core Really Is 2019-06-27 10:00:00These movement screens will allow you to assess your core stability and conduct core strength tests. See if you know how to use and move your core. &

What Is Functional Training? 2019-06-25 17:15:00Many buzzwords seem to fly around the fitness industry, and "functional" seems to be the most common one. Many buzzwords seem to fly around the fitn

The Secret to Your First Squat is Feeling 2019-06-23 11:22:50Here's where you start to focus on the feeling of a good squat because it's a great feeling. It’s all patterns. Learning to squat is learning

Preserve the Habit at All Costs: Why You 2019-06-21 15:36:40Conventional wisdom tells us we shouldn't work out every day, especially early on, but the opposite is actually true. “We are mere bundles of h

Slay the Dragon: Techniques to Conquer Fear 2019-06-20 09:10:48It’s about changing your impression of what difficult is, and who you are when you meet it. It’s easy to see its green scales when you&rsq

7 Parts of the Body That Need More 2019-06-06 20:10:59Here are seven stretches to do after lifting sessions for the areas of the body we often forget about. The debate about stretching—dynamic versu

The Locomotion Workout 2019-06-06 06:01:45This workout combines normal patterns with movement in order to reveal blind spots and keep passion alive. Training is hard. Even for the most dedicat

T Nation Articles

Tip: Eat More, Train More – The Anabolic 2019-07-02 07:00:00How do you eat for gains without gaining excess fat? Like this.

Primer 52: The Program 2019-07-01 08:00:00Completely reshape your body with this sophisticated and straightforward diet and training plan.

Tip: 40-Plus? Do More Work 2019-07-01 07:00:00Here's why this counterintuitive advice actually makes a lot of sense.

Tip: Bench Like a Beast Without Shoulder Pain 2019-06-30 07:00:00Here are three ways to build upper-body strength without irritating your well-worn shoulder joints.

Tip: Do Tinder and Steroids Go Hand-in-Hand? 2019-06-29 07:00:00A new study found a connection between fans of dating apps and their use of steroids, bodybuilding supplements, and fasting.

The 7 Most Important Lifts 2019-06-28 08:00:00Quick, name the seven most effective exercises. Got it? Now see if your list matches ours.

Tip: Ramping Up the Reverse Hyper 2019-06-28 07:00:00Turn this exercise into an isometric hold for greater strength gains. Here's how.

Worthy vs. Worthless Vitamins: Your Guide 2019-06-27 08:00:00A lot of the most commonly taken vitamins and minerals are a tragic waste of money, but there are a few that you definitely need to take.

Tip: The Athlete's Push-Up 2019-06-27 07:00:00Build starting strength and reactive power with this challenging push-up variation.

9 Underrated Exercises You Need 2019-06-26 08:00:00Stop missing out. Build a leaner, stronger, more jacked physique with this list of underused moves.

Arm Day Annihilation 2019-06-17 08:00:00Sorry, but just doing compound lifts isn't going to grow your arms to their maximal genetic limits. You need an arm day full of supersets. Try these.

Tip: How to Diagnose Your Bench Press Problem 2019-06-17 07:00:00Bench stuck? Here's how to find and fix your sticking points.

FieldandStream.com

A Fishing Adventure with Old Pals on the 2019-07-01 19:00:52A buddy rafting and fishing adventure down the New River.

The 12 Most Classic Lures and Flies for 2019-07-01 14:18:38Twelve of the most effective lures and flies for catching freshwater fish all summer.

Is the Shock Collar on Your Bird Dog 2019-06-28 19:00:32Some dog trainers swear by e-collars while others wouldn’t take a case of them for free. Whether or not you choose to use a shock collar is some

Better Than Sunblock: Sun Protection Clothing to Save 2019-06-28 16:36:00If you fish a lot but don’t want to deal with the hassle of slathering lotion all over yourself a couple of times a day, consider purchasing clo

The Next Three Things to Buy After You've 2019-06-28 16:10:43Just bought your first fishing kayak? Welcome to a great sport! Catch fish, get exercise, spend more time outside. Just make sure you’re safe on

Three Things To Look For In a Fishing 2019-06-28 14:25:00You can fish casually out of just about any kayak, as long as it floats. But if you’re serious about catching fish you should consider buying a

Bowhunting Hogs at Night Is the Can’t-Miss Hunt 2019-06-28 14:17:40How stage a can't-miss bow hunt for wild hogs at night

Two Reasons You Might Be Missing 2019-06-27 19:00:16Spin drift refers to the tendency of a bullet to drift either left or right, depending on the direction of its rifling twist. Both this and the Coriol

How to Pick The Right Kind of Fishing 2019-06-27 18:05:00Not all fishing lines are the same. Use the wrong kind in the wrong situation and you will find it much harder to catch fish. There are three main typ

Hook Shots: Go Go Team Snakehead (Chapter 1) 2019-06-27 14:33:00No matter how you feel about snakeheads, one cannot deny that the cult of anglers that targets them for sport grows annually. Many of them—inclu

Pennsylvania Grandmother Kills Cobra With a Shovel 2019-06-27 14:00:28Kathy Kehoe, a 73-year-old grandmother and school bus driver from Falls, Pa., was forced to kill a dangerous, exotic snake that is thought to have esc

How Reading Trout Water Can Make You a 2019-06-26 14:03:22Learn how to read trout water like a fishing guide.


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.